Sean Dunne appeals judge's refusal over cross-examination of bankruptcy official

Sean Dunne appeals judge's refusal over cross-examination of bankruptcy official

Sean Dunne has appealed a judge's refusal to permit him cross-examine his Irish bankruptcy official in a forthcoming hearing aimed at extending the developer's bankruptcy over alleged non-cooperation and hiding income and assets.

Mr Dunne, adjudicated bankrupt here in July 2013, was due to exit bankruptcy in July 2016 but cannot pending the hearing of the application by official assignee Chris Lehane to extend it by the maximum five years permissible.

Mr Dunne opposes any extension and the High Court was previously told it is of "paramount importance" to him to "get free of the shackles of bankruptcy".

Sean Dunne appeals judge's refusal over cross-examination of bankruptcy official

Today, Mr Dunne appealed to the Court of Appeal against the High Court's refusal last February to permit cross-examination of Mr Lehane in the extension hearing.

Ms Justice Caroline Costello said she was unable to identify conflicts in affidavits of Mr Dunne and Mr Lehane "relevant to the issues to be determined" so as to make cross-examination of Mr Lehane necessary to justly decide the extension application.

Outlining the appeal, Bill Shipsey SC, for Mr Dunne, argued the developer is entitled under rules governing bankruptcy to cross examine Mr Lehane about the basis for his application. The High Court also has discretion to direct cross-examination, he said.

There was no basis for extending the bankruptcy and a number of affidavits from Mr Dunne showed "manifest contests" concerning Mr Lehane's allegations.

The fact Mr Lehane had been provided with relevant documents and materials via the US trustee administering Mr Dunne's bankruptcy there was also an example of his client's co-operation, counsel added.

Mark Sanfey SC, for Mr Lehane, argued Mr Dunne had failed in his affidavits to show a serious dispute on the facts on which Mr Lehane based his belief underlining the extension application and there was no basis for cross-examination.

An example of non co-operation was Mr Dunne had given Mr Lehane his address as a property in Connecticut which is "unoccupied and unfurnished", counsel said.

Mr Dunne was also not entitled to "thumb his nose" at Mr Lehane by asserting co-operation with his US trustee was sufficient to establish co-operation in his Irish bankruptcy.

The High Court had found affidavits from Mr Dunne had not contested most of the facts concerning his engagement with Mr Lehane and the most recent affidavit from Mr Dunne did not change the position, he argued.

At the conclusion of arguments, the three judge Court of Appeal, comprising Ms Justice Mary Finlay Geoghegan, Mr Justice Michael Peart and Mr Justice Gerard Hogan, reserved judgment to a later date.

Ulster Bank had petitioned the High Court in February 2013 to have Mr Dunne adjudicated bankrupt here over default on some €164m loans.

The following month, Mr Dunne filed for bankruptcy in Connecticut, US, when he claimed to have debts of $1bn and assets of $55m. In July 2013, he was adjudicated bankrupt here.

In seeking to cross-examine Mr Lehane, Mr Dunne said the latter had made specific allegations concerning the Lagoon beach hotel in South Africa; "Walford", Shrewsbury Road, Ballsbridge, and a property at Churchfields, the K Club, Straffan, Co Kildare.

Mr Lehane disputes the validity of transfers of those properties by Mr Dunne, has obtained freezing orders concerning the Lagoon Beach hotel and has also taken proceedings against Gayle Dunne and John Dunne, a son of Sean Dunne.

More on this topic

Book of evidence prepared against member of gardaíBook of evidence prepared against member of gardaí

Woman's hotel stay in Cork ends in arrest after teacups and glasses thrown at the wallWoman's hotel stay in Cork ends in arrest after teacups and glasses thrown at the wall

Teen wrapped chain around knuckles for assaultTeen wrapped chain around knuckles for assault

Trial of garda accused of assaulting RTÉ cameraman hears protestors became 'extremely aggressive'Trial of garda accused of assaulting RTÉ cameraman hears protestors became 'extremely aggressive'


More in this Section

New research study to explore long-term effects of repeated concussionNew research study to explore long-term effects of repeated concussion

Man appears in court in connection with Dublin robberyMan appears in court in connection with Dublin robbery

10 of 31 local authorities publish political donations given to councillors10 of 31 local authorities publish political donations given to councillors

Robert Lawlor found not guilty of threatening to murder ex-girlfriend's partnerRobert Lawlor found not guilty of threatening to murder ex-girlfriend's partner


Lifestyle

As David Attenborough announces new series on plants, we run down some of the weird and wonderful vegetation he might include.11 bizarre plant species from around the world

The weather’s always going to be a key factor on any wedding day — but especially so when the bride works for Met Éireann, writes Eve Kelliher.Wedding of the week: Bride and groom are literally on cloud nine

My wife and I are in our fifties and she has just started using porn. She thinks it will enhance our sex life if we watch it together, but I find the idea a total turn-off.Suzi Godson's Sex Advice: My wife wants us to watch porn together?

As you probably have heard by now, changes to the rules concerning gift vouchers in Ireland came into effect earlier this month, giving consumers more rights when it comes to these popular items.Making Cents: Play your cards right when giving gift vouchers this Christmas

More From The Irish Examiner