Ruling in Alan Shatter case may be appealed further, says legal expert

Ruling in Alan Shatter case may be appealed further, says legal expert

A legal expert has said that the Court of Appeal's ruling in the Alan Shatter case is dramatic and may be appealed further.

The court yesterday upheld an appeal by the former Justice Minister, who said that he should have been interviewed before the release of the Guerin Report.

The publication of the report two years ago prompted his resignation as Minister, but his handling of the issues concerned was later vindicated by a Commission of Investigation.

Dr Tom Hickey of DCU said the court's decision is a significant one.

"It may well be the case that Sean Guerin should have consulted Alan Shatter, you know, as a matter of courtesy or maybe even to do the job well, but that judges would subsequently quash the findings based on the idea that they feel that he ought to have, I think, really is really quite a robust step taken by the judiciary," he said.

More in this Section

Limerick people 'grossly insulted' by Micheál Martin's ministerial choices - Willie O'DeaLimerick people 'grossly insulted' by Micheál Martin's ministerial choices - Willie O'Dea

Politicians should ‘lead by example’, says Leo VaradkarPoliticians should ‘lead by example’, says Leo Varadkar

Sentence for teen who attempted to murder woman he met on dating app too lenient, court declaresSentence for teen who attempted to murder woman he met on dating app too lenient, court declares

Johnson and Sturgeon governments clash over air bridgesJohnson and Sturgeon governments clash over air bridges


Lifestyle

For 2020, statement-making in interiors has expanded to just about anything we like as long as it draws the eye towards it in the way a fireplace or television dominating a room would typically have done in the past, writes Carol O'CallaghanHow just one item can create a focal point in a room and even spark a conversation

Dara McAnulty talks about his friendship with Chris Packham, his struggles with autism and the buzz around his debut book.Dara McAnulty: Meet the bright new teenage voice for conservation

'You see, in a classroom, I know the rules. I’m not perfect but I’m in the right ballpark at least. I can see and hear it in my students’ reactions, in their contributions from the stands.'Secret Diary of an Irish Teacher: Living the dream in a lockdown nightmare

'The old doll said we can’t go to Tenerife this year because her Mam would be ashamed if she went against the government's advice, whoever's in the government these days.'Ask Audrey: 'C’mere, what’s the story with getting ripped off by Kerry people?'

More From The Irish Examiner