Report finds article in Constitution relating to woman's place in the home has 'no place' in 21st century Ireland

Report finds article in Constitution relating to woman's place in the home has 'no place' in 21st century Ireland

The Government has been presented with two options to remove the “sexist and paternalistic” Article 41.2 of the Constitution which relates to woman's place in the home.

The Oireachtas Justice Committee report has concluded the article as currently worded has “no place in the Ireland of the 21st century”.

“There is no reasonable argument or justification for retaining the current provision," the report said.

"The question, therefore, is not whether to delete the Article, but whether it should be deleted simpliciter or replaced with an alternative wording that is more appropriate to the present day and that reflects the value and recognition we wish to place on the role of carers in our society, not just in the traditional family home setting, but more broadly,” the report stated.

The committee could not reach a consensus on a recommendation so has put forward two alternative options for the Government to consider.

Some members favour replacing Article 41.2 with an alternative provision containing more appropriate, gender-neutral language, which acknowledges the support that home and family life gives to society, and the importance of the role played by carers, whilst ensuring that the Government and the Oireachtas remain responsible for the allocation of public funds.

They recommend replacing the existing Article 41.2 with the following:

The State recognises that home and family life gives to society a support without which the common good cannot be achieved. The State shall endeavour to support persons caring for others within the home as may be determined by law.

Other members support the view expressed by a number of stakeholders in the course of the hearings that these complex issues require time for public engagement, and a conversation that considers a range of constitutional, legislative and policy options in this area.

They therefore call upon the Government, before proceeding with a referendum in 2019, to establish and engage in a public consultation process – an obvious possible model being how the Citizens’ Assembly addressed the issues around the eighth amendment.

The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission welcomed the publication of Oireachtas Joint Committee on Justice and Equality report.

“It is clear from its recommendations that there is cross-party support within the Committee for an amendment which recognises the public good provided by care work within and by families in Ireland," Emily Logan, chief commissioner of the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission, added.

More in this Section

Coronavirus: No deaths in North reported so far this weekCoronavirus: No deaths in North reported so far this week

UL becomes first Irish university to appoint woman as leaderUL becomes first Irish university to appoint woman as leader

40% of childcare creches may not reopen as sector plunged into 'chaos'40% of childcare creches may not reopen as sector plunged into 'chaos'

Financial services provider in Dublin searched as part of fraud investigationFinancial services provider in Dublin searched as part of fraud investigation


Lifestyle

Is there a natural treatment I could use instead of steroids and antibiotic drops for dry eye?Natural health: I suffer from chronic dry eye

Denise O’Donoghue checks in with several expats affected by the cancellation of shows in BritainIrish actors on the crisis the West End theatre industry faces

This month marks four decades since the release of the classic record that would also be Ian Curtis’s final album with Joy Division. Ed Power chats to a number of Cork music fans about what it meant to themJoy Division: Forty years on from Closer

Last week, I shared my lockdown experience. I asked for a more uniform approach, should there be another lockdown. I explained that I worked mornings. Maybe I should have been more specific: working 8am to 1pm without a break, I gave feedback and covered the curriculum, using our school’s online platform. In the afternoons, I looked after my three kids (all under ten) while my husband worked. It was a challenging time for everyone and the uncertainty around what I should have been doing as a teacher made it harder.Diary of an Irish teacher: I want to get back to work. But I would like to do it safely

More From The Irish Examiner