Rental firm ordered to pay €61k to General Manager effectively demoted after returning from maternity leave

Rental firm ordered to pay €61k to General Manager effectively demoted after returning from maternity leave

A rental company has been ordered to pay €61,100 to a General Manager after she found herself to be effectively demoted to general operative on returning from maternity leave.

At the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC), WRC Adjudication Officer James Kelly has ordered the unnamed business to pay the worker €53,000 after finding that she was discriminated against on the grounds of pregnancy.

Mr Kelly has ordered the firm to pay the woman an additional €8,000 after finding that she was victimised by her employer under the Employment Equality Act. The WRC has also ordered the employer to pay the woman €100 for a breach of the Terms of Employment (Information) Act.

In the case, the woman gave birth to her fourth child in December 2016. On her return from maternity leave in September 2017, the woman felt that she had been effectively demoted.

In his findings, Mr Kelly said: “I am satisfied that the picture she paints is not one of General Manager and more of general operative. Her role has diminished and how she is spoken to is blunt and an unacceptable manner in this work environment.

“I accept her evidence that her role had changed, and her tasks and responsibilities were reduced from her pre-maternity status.”

The woman resigned from her post in March 2018 and she failed in a separate claim of constructive dismissal against the company.

The company told the hearing that the woman was the most senior member of staff who had presided over significant growth within the business and at all times completed her duties to a high standard.

The woman was on an annual salary of €70,000 and had the use of a work car and work mobile phone.

In her evidence to the WRC, the woman stated that on her return to work in September 2017, the owner told her that “there was big changes around here” and that another female employee will have a role to “oversee everyone’s work”.

The General Manager told the hearing that she was shocked that on her first day back to work she was ambushed and effectively told that her role would be diminishing, and she would be de facto demoted, which she claims amounts to discriminatory treatment.

At work on September 8, 2017, the General Manager said that she felt that she was not wanted and not welcome back in the workplace after the owner told her in an exchange: “I don’t care what you do; Do whatever you like.”

The worker maintained that the shocking treatment she was subjected to on her return to work was motivated by the fact that she availed of her statutory right to additional maternity leave and was de facto demoted and forced out of her job.

On September 12, 2017, the General Manager commenced a period of medically certified unpaid sick leave due to work-related stress and she remained on sick leave until her resignation.

In his evidence, the owner denied saying any words that did not make the complainant feel welcome on her return to work or that undermined her role.

The owner strongly denied the General Manager’s allegations.

He stated that she was an integral part of the growth of the company and was considered to be all but irreplaceable. Her absence and ultimate resignation from the company caused enormous operational difficulties

In February 2018, the owner wrote to the complainant’s solicitors to say that he had worked with the employee for 22 years and had always had a good working relationship with her.

He said that “I sincerely wish to encourage her to return to work within the group. Naturally, in any working relationship, there can be ebbs and flows in a busy working environment but after 22 years I have to believe that her grievances can be resolved and that we can continue our own direct working longstanding working relationship between her and the company, with mutual trust and confidence”.

Mr Kelly found that the worker was victimised over her employer removing from her the company mobile which she had used for a number of years.

He said that “removing her work mobile phone from her without prior notice was a detriment. It caused her stress and anxiety as she was not contactable as a mother of young children”.

More on this topic

Man loses case for unfair dismissal after public body sacks him for missing almost 300 days in a yearMan loses case for unfair dismissal after public body sacks him for missing almost 300 days in a year

Council ordered to re-instate 'retired' 68-year-old lorry driver and employ him until his 70th birthday Council ordered to re-instate 'retired' 68-year-old lorry driver and employ him until his 70th birthday

Workers need more support from employers when upskilling, report suggests Workers need more support from employers when upskilling, report suggests

Leading Muslim figure claims he was fired from Trinity College over female circumcision commentsLeading Muslim figure claims he was fired from Trinity College over female circumcision comments


More in this Section

Concern for children's safety following 'alleged suspicious approach' in DublinConcern for children's safety following 'alleged suspicious approach' in Dublin

More focus on livelihoods needed in Brexit talks, says Micheál Martin More focus on livelihoods needed in Brexit talks, says Micheál Martin 

Ireland’s only dedicated track for car drifting facing uncertain futureIreland’s only dedicated track for car drifting facing uncertain future

Emergency care resources 'highly skewed' to North East, study findsEmergency care resources 'highly skewed' to North East, study finds


Lifestyle

The American heritage brand has put together a collection inspired by the most stylish Friends character.This is why Rachel Green’s style is the epitome of Ralph Lauren – as a new collection is announced

When starting out as a comedian, Cork man Andrew Ryan decided to go to straight to London, sidestepping the usual starting ground of Irish clubs and pubs.Cork comedian Andrew Ryan is 'a cross between Ardal O’Hanlon and Ed Byrne'

Rachel Marie Walsh knows the best eyeliners to try this season.Beauty is in the eye of the beholder: Essential eyeliners for a killer look

Paul McLauchlan has the lowdown from London Fashion Week. Here’s all you need to know about next season.London Fashion Week: How you’ll dress for the next decade

More From The Irish Examiner