Q&A: What you need to know as the Government decide to publish report on Public Services Card

Q&A: What you need to know as the Government decide to publish report on Public Services Card

What has happened now?

The Department of Social Protection has agreed to publish the Data Protection Commissioner’s distinctly adversarial report into the Public Services Card at an indeterminate date in the future as it has yet to “fully consider” its implications.

Is this controversial?

Yes, but it’s not entirely unexpected. The Department has been operating from a basis of more or less radio silence since the DPC announced last week that her investigation had almost entirely gone against what Social Protection has been saying for a year - that the expansion of the card to State services like driving licence and passport applications was entirely legal. The DPC said today it “regrets” the report is not being immediately published and it can see no reason why it isn’t being released at this time.

Does it change much?

It’s significant that the Department has now made an absolute commitment to publish the report. However, the question is when. The Department has said it expects its consultations with the Attorney General and the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform regarding its response to the report will take “another week or so”. But again, that doesn’t clarify when the report will finally be released.

Why is this controversial?

For any number of reasons. An interim report into the card was released to the Department fully 12 months ago, with conclusions unchanged from the final report according to the Commissioner. That means that the Department has had a full year to consider the implications of the report, yet is now asking for more time.

What difference another week makes - assuming that it is only a week - is perhaps moot, but it could certainly be argued that the report could be released immediately without greatly altering much other than the Department’s own response.

Is much riding on this?

An enormous amount, as the PSC has turned into something of a political grenade with the pin taken out. Both the Ministers for Public Expenditure and Social Protection, Paschal Donohoe and Regina Doherty respectively, are now in the unenviable position of having to explain their actions over the past year despite having no obvious escape outlet open to them.

While the Commissioner’s findings are known, her reasons for arriving at those conclusions will not become fully clear until the report is in the public domain.

In the meantime it’s hard to conclude that the latest delay will allow for much other than a face-saving exercise on the part of the two departments, who will have to make their case for why they pushed on with the PSC project despite being told in no uncertain terms that to do so would be illegal 12 months ago.

More on this topic

€9.4m development of new Public Services Card to be completed in January€9.4m development of new Public Services Card to be completed in January

Passport Office deciding 'on an ad hoc basis' whether to renew documents without Public Services CardPassport Office deciding 'on an ad hoc basis' whether to renew documents without Public Services Card

'We have to see it' - Fianna Fáil insists Govt must publish Public Services Card report'We have to see it' - Fianna Fáil insists Govt must publish Public Services Card report

'It's not legal' - Social Democrats question Regina Doherty's position over public services card'It's not legal' - Social Democrats question Regina Doherty's position over public services card


More in this Section

Fairhill man bound to peace and fined for assaulting neighbourFairhill man bound to peace and fined for assaulting neighbour

10 charges brought against teenager after March collision that injured Cork toddler10 charges brought against teenager after March collision that injured Cork toddler

€9.4m development of new Public Services Card to be completed in January€9.4m development of new Public Services Card to be completed in January

Justice Minister calls for direct provision centre protesters to 'step back'Justice Minister calls for direct provision centre protesters to 'step back'


Lifestyle

Make-up artist Terry Barber reveals the secret to pulling off the bold lip look.This is how to make black lipstick work in real life, according to a catwalk make-up pro

Off to the Japan? After a trip to Tokyo, Ella Walker outlines the best things to eat between matches.These are the dishes to try if you’re going to Tokyo for the Rugby World Cup

It still surprises me as I am achingly private and do not enjoy being at the centre of attention.This Much I Know: Actor Aislin McGuckin

Bride Geraldine O’Donovan felt as wonderful as she looked on her big day — knowing she was supporting a cause close to her heart as she donned her wedding gown.Wedding on the Week: Supporting a cause close to their hearts

More From The Irish Examiner