Probation Service and Rape Crisis Network back draft sex-offender laws

Probation Service and Rape Crisis Network back draft sex-offender laws

The Probation Service and Rape Crisis Network Ireland have backed draft laws regarding the disclosure of information, electronic tagging and restricting foreign travels of convicted sex offenders.

But the head of the Probation Service Vivian Geiran cautioned that there was “no silver bullet” in terms of legislative or technical measures that will stop sex offenders from carrying out more crimes.

He was addressing the Oireachtas Justice Committee, which is considering both the Government's General Scheme of the Sex Offenders Bill 2018 and a Private Member's Bill, the Sex Offenders (Amendment) Bill 2018.

Senior officers from the PSNI, who attended the hearing, said legal powers in the North preventing a convicted sex offender from travelling abroad were rarely-used but an “essential part” or their armoury.

Probation Service and Rape Crisis Network back draft sex-offender laws

But law lecturer Margaret Fitzgerald O’Reilly expressed concerns around proposed provisions regarding travel restrictions, tagging and disclosure and said any such powers should be based on evidence and be both “necessary and proportionate”.

Included in the Government's bill is a provision allowing for a mid-ranking garda to disclose information to the public or a member of the public in the interests of their protection. This information could include the name, address and level of risk posed by a sex offender.

The bill will also allow for the electronic tagging of an offender as part of a sex offender order.

Separately, the Private Member's Bill, tabled by Maureen O'Sullivan TD for Dublin Central, provides for a court to restrict convicted sex offenders from travelling abroad and engage in child sex tourism.

Ms O'Sullivan addressed the hearing and said the impetus for her bill came from meetings with Irish priest, Fr Shay Cullen, who is directly involved in rescuing children from the sex tourism industry in the Philippines.

Fr Shay Cullen
Fr Shay Cullen

She said the bill recognises the constitutional right to travel, but balances that against the need to protect the rights of children abroad.

Mr Geiran described both bills as providing “very significant” improvements in the legal area.

The Probation Service Director said the issue in the Government's bill of disclosure was the provision where “most caution” was needed.

He said it had “huge potential for harm as well as good” depending on how it was framed.

He said he was concerned that uncontrolled disclosure of information regarding a sex offender could drive offenders underground, making their job of supervision more difficult and increasing the risk of reoffending.

Probation Deputy Director Ita Burke said electronic tagging was most effective when part of a risk management strategy and that it had proved effective in other jurisdictions in such situations. She said the Probation Service “saw value” in what the legislation was proposing.

Mr Geiran said he recognised Dr Fitzgerald O’Reilly's concerns regarding the provision on restricting travel, but added that he agreed with the PSNI view that this power “would be quite useful”.

PSNI Assistant Chief Constable Barbara Gray said the provision was a “useful piece of legislation”, while PSNI Detective Superintendent Ryan Henderson said it was an “essential part of the armoury”, though it was rarely used.

Caroline Counihan of the RCNI said the provisions in both bills were very welcome and represent “significant increases” in legal powers.

She shared concerns regarding unregulated disclosure, saying the potential of driving offenders underground was a “huge concern” and said there needed to be penalties for misusing the information. She also said the travel provision would need to be “framed properly” to isolate any legal challenges.

Dr Fitzgerald O’Reilly said empirical research did not show disclosure was effective. She said it should only be done where it was “necessary and proportionate” and that there should be express confidentiality on the information provided.

She said research indicated electronic tagging was not effective in terms of preventing reoffending or deterrence – but said it may have a role in monitoring adherence to registration requirements. She said it was also very costly.

In relation to travel, she said there was no evidence to show it was effective. She said the wording left the provision “very exposed to be challenged” given its interference with constitutional rights to travel and liberty and would need to be reframed and tightened, perhaps as part of the Government's bill.

More on this topic

Third of UK women subjected to unwanted violence during sex – surveyThird of UK women subjected to unwanted violence during sex – survey

Case Studies: Child watchdog slams 'absolutely despicable' delays in establishing sexual abuse servicesCase Studies: Child watchdog slams 'absolutely despicable' delays in establishing sexual abuse services

Treatment delays for young people who have experienced sexual assault detrimental to recoveryTreatment delays for young people who have experienced sexual assault detrimental to recovery

'It’s not your fault': Consent campaign targets college students ahead of Fresher's Week'It’s not your fault': Consent campaign targets college students ahead of Fresher's Week


More in this Section

Greyhound track protestors 'delighted with outcome' as they reach settlement with Shelbourne ParkGreyhound track protestors 'delighted with outcome' as they reach settlement with Shelbourne Park

Conor McGregor escapes prosecution for motoring offencesConor McGregor escapes prosecution for motoring offences

Man was traveling at 165km/hr in 100km/hr zone before fatal accident, inquest hearsMan was traveling at 165km/hr in 100km/hr zone before fatal accident, inquest hears

Injunction restrains gardaí interviewing boy, 14, over alleged sexual contact with 12-year-oldInjunction restrains gardaí interviewing boy, 14, over alleged sexual contact with 12-year-old


Lifestyle

They’re still a fairly new phenomenon on the interiors scene, but the growing popularity of listening to podcasts has provided us with an easy-to-access source of ideas and advice, writes Carol O’Callaghan.Listen and learn: How podcasts can help you source cool interiors ideas

Live your cheese dream for one night only.Video: The world’s first cheese hotel has opened its doors

For Galway-based nature lover and grandmother, Marion Edler-Burke, forest-walking is balm for the soul.Parents for the Planet: It’s revitalising to see the wood and the trees

Working outside in your front garden can help people meet and encourage neighbours to become friends, says Hannah Stephenson.How your garden can help you make new friends

More From The Irish Examiner