Murphy 'not living in the real world' with 'harsh' housing proposal, opposition TDs claim

Murphy 'not living in the real world' with 'harsh' housing proposal, opposition TDs claim
Housing Minister Eoghan Murphy

Housing Minister Eoghan Murphy has come under attack for radical proposals to “punish” families on housing lists, who refuse offers, by putting back their potential waiting time by five years.

The contentious proposal was debated in the Dáil today and saw Opposition TDs round on the minister, with claims he was “not living in the real world”, and likely changes were “very harsh”.

Under the plan, social housing applicants who reject two home offers within 12 months will see their waiting period set back by five years. Currently, the sanction after two home rejections is a year extra.

Mr Murphy insisted the sanction of a one-year delay was not working and refusals by those on the list were impacting on efforts to reduce the 70,000 housing applicants on waiting lists.

But Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett claimed there was a type of “victim blaming” underway against the homeless. He cited comments by Dublin City Council CEO Owen Keegan who, last weekend, claimed better homeless services were attracting people.

The latest social housing proposal from the minister was an “absolute disgrace”, diverting attention away from delays and blaming victims, argued the Solidarity/PBP TD.

Mr Barrett said many families if offered a home, in a particular area, could "not uproot" their kids, especially if the offer for a home was in a location without transport or where the property was substandard, too small or not suitable in general.

He said the minister was willing to “punish” people who refused offers by making them wait another five years.

Mr Murphy, however, said the changes were part of a suite of measures, to be agreed by Government in the coming weeks. The new rules were fair for those on waiting lists and were intended to target people refusing to take up offers for “frivolous” or “spurious” reasons.

Labour's Jan O'Sullivan accused him of “not living in the real world” and said the changes were "very harsh". Despite assurances by the minister, Ms O'Sullivan said she believed local authorities would "not show flexibility" with the new rules.

Meanwhile, Mr Murphy advised that the government will still hold a referendum on whether water should be protected in public ownership but that the vote must “not be rushed”.

He told the Dáil that wording for the referendum was still being worked on by the Attorney General, among others, before it is debated in Leinster House.

Fianna Fail's Darragh O'Brien pushed Mr Murphy to commit to when the vote could be held, further details about it, and when the transfer of water assets from local authorities to Irish Water would be completed.

Minister Murphy said that the government had decided against having the vote in May due to the need to get the language right over the contentious issue of group and private water schemes.

The decision to postpone the referendum has been viewed by Opposition TDs as a way to avoid any further controversy or backlash over water in the lead up to the May local and European elections.

More on this topic

'They thought of everything': Age-specific housing in East Cork'They thought of everything': Age-specific housing in East Cork

Vittorio Bufacchi: People in direct provision could be the key to housing crisisVittorio Bufacchi: People in direct provision could be the key to housing crisis

Just 16 applications for year-round short-term lets lodged in Dublin cityJust 16 applications for year-round short-term lets lodged in Dublin city

UCC students prepared to strike if rent hike goes aheadUCC students prepared to strike if rent hike goes ahead


More in this Section

'How does that represent change?' - Social Democrats TD would be 'massively uncomfortable' with FF/FG govt'How does that represent change?' - Social Democrats TD would be 'massively uncomfortable' with FF/FG govt

High Court allows HSE to detain 'debilitated' woman in hospital who had been living in 'dire' conditionsHigh Court allows HSE to detain 'debilitated' woman in hospital who had been living in 'dire' conditions

Garda Commissioner: I will work with any elected government including a Sinn Féin-led oneGarda Commissioner: I will work with any elected government including a Sinn Féin-led one

Jogger injured by horse on gallops at Curragh Racecourse loses High Court damages claimJogger injured by horse on gallops at Curragh Racecourse loses High Court damages claim


Lifestyle

Not all trends are created equal. Some are exciting – like first-date butterflies; others are comforting – like ice-cream and Golden Girls reruns.Trend of the Week: Floral free for all

Veterinary medicine is a demanding career, leading to mental health problems for some vets.Elephant in the clinic: Helpline offers support to vets with mental health difficulties

Pearl Lowe turns 50 in April – and she’s got a lot to celebrate. TA look into the reinvention of Pearl Lowe

Bonnie Ryan couldn’t be happier.On a roll: Why Bonnie Ryan couldn't be happier

More From The Irish Examiner