Man accused of murdering member of rival motorcycle club 'panicked', jury hears

The barrister for a man accused of murdering a member of a rival motorcycle club in Limerick says it was not a planned and cold-blooded killing.

He was addressing the jury for a final time on behalf of Alan McNamara from Mountfune in Murroe, Co Limerick, who claims he acted in self-defence.

Alan McNamara

Defence barrister Hugh Hartnett began his closing speech by describing the case as tragic – tragic because of the way Andrew O’Donoghue died, and tragic that his client - a happy, family man with a love of horses and motorbikes - is now before a jury charged with his murder.

He said Mr McNamara accepted killing him, but the real question is what caused that to happen and what was in his mind before that.

He said he woke up on July 20, 2015 full of panic after being assaulted and threatened by members of the Road Tramps MC the day before.

He heard Harleys gathering at their clubhouse nearby and he thought they were planning to harm them so he went up there with a gun.

When he arrived, he said he thought he was looking at men with guns so he panicked and fired the gun, hitting Mr O’Donoghue in the head.

He said Mr McNamara insisted he acted in self defence and urged the jury to return a verdict of manslaughter instead of murder.

More on this topic

Man arrested after discovery of a suspect device denied bail

Judge seeks statements in Cork incinerator dispute

West Cork 'chop shop' operator jailed for two years for part in €500k stolen car operation

'Love triangle' trial: Accused told garda there were only two tanks on the farm

More in this Section

Sinn Fein to meet police over failure to reveal material on mass shooting

Pope has chance to change church's response to scandal, campaigner says

Protesters gather outside home of Minister Richard Bruton

Council ‘committed’ to restoring Stansted route from City of Derry Airport


Outside the box: A tale of two Calais and suffering beyond reason

Opening Lines: I feel sorry for the dogs. Even they have a sense of shame about having to poo in public

New TV show highlights lack of cycle lanes in Ireland in comparison to rest of Europe

Online Lives: Creator of popular health and lifestyle blog Sarah Dwan

More From The Irish Examiner