Major setback for Seann Quinn's children in €410m liability case

Major setback for Seann Quinn's children in €410m liability case

Settlement talks are underway in the marathon case by Sean Quinn’s five adult children denying liability for some €410m under guarantees of loans advanced by Anglo Irish Bank to Quinn companies.

Mr Justice Garrett Simons was told of the development at the High Court today, just after he ruled the children cannot pursue claims their father unduly influenced them to sign the securities and "effectively dictated" to them about the lending.

That ruling is a major setback for the children whose counsel Bernard Dunleavy SC argued they would be "significantly prejudiced" if not permitted make that claim.

Irish Bank Resolution Corporation (IBRC), into which Anglo was nationalised following its collapse, strongly opposed the children being permitted to make the claim in their case against IBRC and a receiver appointed over share charges.

In his ruling, the judge disagreed a claim of undue influence against Sean Quinn Senior already exists within the children’s pleaded claim and refused to permit them to amend their case and witness statements to specifically make that claim.

The proposed amendments were not necessary for deciding the "real issues" and would cause "real prejudice" to the defence as it would have to meet an "entirely different" case, he ruled.

The lack of detail in the proposed amendments meant it “is impossible for the bank to know the case that it is now expected to meet", he added.

After his ruling, Mr Dunleavy SC, with Ciarán Lewis SC, for the Quinns, said they had used the time in recent days for discussions which are continuing. Paul Gallagher SC, with Barry O'Donnell SC, for IBRC, confirmed that.

The judge welcomed that news and adjourned the case to tomorrow to facilitate talks.

Brenda Quinn, the first witness, was due to begin evidence last Friday but that was deferred due to the procedural applications.

In his ruling, the judge noted the children sought to impugn share charges allegedly executed by them between January 2003 and March 2009 and personal guarantees of about October 2008 on grounds including undue influence and improvident or unconscionable bargain.

In some cases, they also alleged "signature switching", that they signed an earlier draft of a share pledge but the signature page was then allegedly wrongfully appended by persons within the Quinn Group to a later revised draft.

Most of the impugned transactions were entered into as part of the unwinding into Anglo shares of Contract for Difference Positions in Anglo built up by Sean Quinn Senior via Bazzely, a company beneficially owned by his children.

Major setback for Seann Quinn's children in €410m liability case

A Supreme Court 2015 decision had significantly narrowed the case as it prevented the Quinns claiming the disputed lending was unenforceable because Anglo acted illegally in breach of Market Abuse Regulations and the Companies Act.

In their existing case, the children alleged undue influence by Anglo, alleging it had insisted, through their father and senior managers of the Quinn group, that all margin calls on CFDs be met on a timely basis and provided the necessary loans, not for the good of the Quinn group but to support its own share price.

The judge said that claim of undue influence by bank officials was abandoned in Mr Dunleavy's opening statement earlier this month which alleged undue influence was exercised by Sean Quinn senior.

Any argument the case as currently formulated includes a claim of undue influence by Sean Quinn senior is "untenable" and wholly inconsistent with the pleadings and conduct of the case to date, he ruled.

He refused to permit the children now amend the claim to allege they took "no active role" concerning the Anglo lending, were "effectively dictated to" by their father and signed documents when he, or personnel within the Quinn group acting on his behalf, told them to.

Those amendments were not necessary to determine the real issues in dispute and introduced an "entirely new" claim inconsistent with the existing claims, he held.

This new claim that Sean Quinn Senior was the "principal wrongdoer" was "crudely bolted" onto the existing case with no attempt made to withdraw the undue influence allegations against Anglo.

An allegation of undue influence is serious but this one is "entirely circular", he said. It was alleged the children were unable to disagree with their father precisely because he exercised influence over them but there were no particulars of the circumstances of the alleged undue influence.

The amendment would cause "real prejudice" to IBRC as the focus of the case would have to shift from the children's dealings with Anglo to their dealings with their father.

That would mean adjourning the case for a considerable period and further delay was "unacceptable" given the history of this case, initiated in 2011, which not just involved the Quinns claims but the bank's counterclaim for €82m each against the children, he said.

The children would have been aware at all stages of their father's alleged undue influence and had not explained their "inordinate" delay in advancing that claim, he said.

More on this topic

Official who shredded key papers to explain decisionOfficial who shredded key papers to explain decision

'Is it more of the roll-over over Leo?' - SF reacts to €270m Anglo payout to junior bondholders'Is it more of the roll-over over Leo?' - SF reacts to €270m Anglo payout to junior bondholders

Irish Banking Resolution Corporation still party to 138 legal actionsIrish Banking Resolution Corporation still party to 138 legal actions

Michael Clifford: Six years behind bars as a banking star crashes to EarthMichael Clifford: Six years behind bars as a banking star crashes to Earth


More in this Section

Storm Atiyah: Flights cancelled, trains delayed in Cork and KerryStorm Atiyah: Flights cancelled, trains delayed in Cork and Kerry

Gardaí renew appeal for information following fatal road collisionGardaí renew appeal for information following fatal road collision

Wild Lights at Dublin Zoo cancelled due to stormWild Lights at Dublin Zoo cancelled due to storm

In pictures: The first look at Storm Atiyah as it hits IrelandIn pictures: The first look at Storm Atiyah as it hits Ireland


Lifestyle

Overshadowed by its giant neighbours it may be, but the smallest of the main Blasket islands, Beginish, is no less impressive in its own right.The Islands of Ireland: The miracle of Beginish

‘The days of our years are threescore years and ten — Psalm 90How to tell an animal’s age in a heartbeat

We often hear how nature will do well, even come back from the brink of extinction, if given a chance and some human help.Birds of prey on the rise

In our country we still have places that bear no evidence of disturbance by man, that are in their pristine state and rich with all the elements that feed the spirit and deliver us into the world beyond the skin of the time and circumstances we live in.Unique ambience of Dursey Island under threat

More From The Irish Examiner