Latest: Counsel for O’Sullivan says he would challenge the credibility and motivation of McCabe again

Latest: Counsel for O’Sullivan says he would challenge the credibility and motivation of McCabe again
Maurice McCabe.

Update 1.32pm: Counsel for Nóirín O’Sullivan says he would challenge the credibility and motivation of Maurice McCabe again if he were asked to do it over.

Colm Smyth said even knowing what he had been through personally, the consequences of not doing so would be worse.

ColmSmythat the Disclosures Tribunal.
Colm Smyth at the Disclosures Tribunal.

Colm Smyth represented the former Garda Commissioner at the O’Higgins Inquiry, where he admitted challenging, but not attacking the motivation and credibility of Maurice McCabe.

The Disclosures Tribunal wants to establish whether Nóirín O'Sullivan relied on unjustified grounds to discredit the whistleblower at the Inquiry.

Former GardaCommissioner, NóirínO'Sullivan.
Former Garda Commissioner, Nóirín O'Sullivan.

Mr Smyth said he was never instructed to challenge Sgt McCabe’s character, but said he had to examine his motivation and credibility in relation to allegations if there was no evidence to back them up.

Counsel for McCabe said it was wrong to challenge credibility and motivation, but Mr Smyth said he had a duty to act in the best interests of his clients, and were he asked to do it again he would, despite what he had been through personally since.

Colm Smyth said he fell on his sword for no person, and he abided by his instructions fully when asked to test the credibility of the allegations.

Earlier: Counsel for Nóirín O’Sullivan at the O’Higgins Commission has told the Disclosures Tribunal that you cannot put things to a witness that are wrong.

Colm Smyth was asked about a five page letter that referred to a complaint made by Maurice McCabe about a superior, when he had made the complaint to the superior.

Mr Smyth said while he did not draft the letter – he accepts responsibility for it.

He said you cannot be making things up, regardless of the contents, you cannot have anything wrong.

- Digital Desk

More on this topic

Garda whistleblower tells tribunal that former assistant commissioner engaged in 'deliberate' cover upGarda whistleblower tells tribunal that former assistant commissioner engaged in 'deliberate' cover up

Garda whistleblower tells tribunal he smuggled printed Pulse files out of garda stationGarda whistleblower tells tribunal he smuggled printed Pulse files out of garda station

Garda whistleblower denies orchestrating campaign 'to end the career' of superintendentGarda whistleblower denies orchestrating campaign 'to end the career' of superintendent

Whistleblower tells tribunal heroin dealer's 'incredible' admission was 'sat on for five months' by GardaíWhistleblower tells tribunal heroin dealer's 'incredible' admission was 'sat on for five months' by Gardaí


More in this Section

Fears doctors overprescribing antidepressants to patientsFears doctors overprescribing antidepressants to patients

Man and woman arrested in connection with Cork arson incidentsMan and woman arrested in connection with Cork arson incidents

Paschal Donohoe 'recoiled' from Noel Grealish's comments about NigeriaPaschal Donohoe 'recoiled' from Noel Grealish's comments about Nigeria

Man to appear in court in connection with cocaine seizure in DroghedaMan to appear in court in connection with cocaine seizure in Drogheda


Lifestyle

Avoid products high in sugar and caffeine, says Helen O’CallaghanEnergy drinks not fit for kids

The staff of Cork Film Festival tell Richard Fitzpatrick about some of their personal recommendations on what to seeInsider tips: Those in the know pick their highlights of the Cork Film Festival

The Cork Film Festival is known for championing short films. We chat to six emerging film-makers who are showing their work over the next few daysCork Film Festival: Short and sweet does the trick

Newsreels from the independence era, and various short films, give a glimpse of earlier eras on Leeside, writes Marjorie BrennanCork Film Festival: Reeling in the years by the Lee

More From The Irish Examiner