Latest: Call for Vatican to pay for Tuam site 'nothing more than a publicity stunt', say survivors

Latest: Call for Vatican to pay for Tuam site 'nothing more than a publicity stunt', say survivors
Pope Francis shakes hands with Katherine Zappone at Aras an Uachtarain as part of his visit to Ireland. Photo: Danny Lawson/PA Wire

By Noel Baker, Social Affairs Correspondent

Update 10.40am: The Tuam Home Survivors Network has savaged the appeal to the Pope by Children's Minister Katherine Zappone for funds for the Mother and Baby Home site, calling it "nothing more than a publicity stunt".

The Minister's direct intervention with Pope Francis during his historic visit has been praised by Tuam historian Catherine Corless and was backed in principle by abuse campaigner Colm O'Gorman, but the Tuam Home Survivors Network said the letter she sent to the Pope "smacks of a stunt".

In a statement the Network, which has 60 members, including people overseas and siblings and cousins of the disappeared, referred to the Minister's reference in the letter issued to Pope Francis in which she said "I am the Minister responsible for the Tuam Mother and Baby Home."

According to the Network: "This is of course an absurd statement. Ms Zappone is merely the Minister to which the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes is to report. In a different country, such a Commission would be reporting to a Justice Minister."

The statement went on: "In the course of her letter to the Pope, she attempts to maintain ... that she with her Cabinet colleagues can decide the future of the mass grave at Tuam. To be clear once more, the only office-holder with jurisdiction over the mass grave at Tuam is the local Coroner."

Earlier: Vatican faces increasing pressure to pay up for Tuam site

By Noel Baker and Juno McEnroe

Update 6.30am: The Vatican is likely to come under increasing pressure to respond to Children’s Minister Katherine Zappone’s direct demand to the Pope that the Church help foot the bill for work on the site of the mother and baby home in Tuam.

Ms Zappone’s extraordinary intervention — first made in Italian when she spoke with the pontiff over the weekend and later in the content of a comprehensive message sent to the Vatican — has been welcomed by campaigners.

It is unclear if the minister’s position is backed by the Government.

Latest: Call for Vatican to pay for Tuam site 'nothing more than a publicity stunt', say survivors

A spokesman refused to clarify if Taoiseach Leo Varadkar knew in advance of Ms Zappone’s intentions to ask the Church to pay. He also refused to say whether the Government supported Ms Zappone’s request.

Minister Zappone will be bringing proposals to Cabinet at a later stage and there will be detailed discussions,” said the spokesman. “The minister had indicated to the Taoiseach that she was planning to raise the matter with Pope Francis.

The spokesman refused to say whether this included the request for the Church to pay for Tuam.

In the letter to the Pope, Ms Zappone said: “It is my strong conviction that given the role of the Church in this shameful chapter of recent Irish history it must play a practical role in addressing the hurt and damage.

“I believe that the church should contribute substantially to the cost of whatever option is decided by the government. This should be done willingly, unconditionally and quickly. Nothing less will demonstrate remorse.”

At the meeting at Áras an Uachtaráin, Ms Zappone told Pope Francis, in Italian: “I am responsible for the Tuam mother and baby home. Children’s remains were found in a sewage system there. I hope the Church will make reparation for its part in this shameful chapter. It is important.”

On the flight back to Rome, the Pope told reporters Ms Zappone had been “very balanced”, adding: “She made me understand that the Church has something to do with this. That lady had a dignity that touched my heart, and now I have the memo there that I will study when I get home.”

Tuam-based historian Catherine Corless, whose work was central to exposing what went on at the mother and baby home and the discovery of human remains, said she saw no reason for the Vatican to delay its response.

There is no need to delay as far as I can see,” she said.

Ms Corless described Ms Zappone’s intervention as “unbelievable” and “courageous”, adding: “As soon as she stepped into the room she took the opportunity, instead of just saying hello, she had a good few words with him.”

As for the subsequent memo to the Vatican, Ms Corless said: “It doesn’t mince any words. It more or less said they have a duty to share the cost.

“It’s not that the State shouldn’t cover it as well, she did not ask for them to cover it in full, but for their share.”

Tuam Survivors Network said it acknowledged Ms Zappone’s intervention but said it was not commenting further at this time.

The site in Tuam is owned by Galway County Council, but the home was run by the Sisters of the Bon Secours. A number of options have been put forward for the site, but that preferred by many locals, and Ms Corless, is for full excavation and exhumation.

A response to the request from the Vatican Press Office was not forthcoming yesterday. The papal nuncio here said it was a matter for the media centre in the Vatican.

As the Government awaits a response from the Vatican, discussion continued following the visit of Pope Francis into how the Church can take practical steps to further bolster the safeguarding of children and to deal with past crimes.

Maeve Lewis, executive director of the group One In Four, said an option was for the Vatican to release records relating to allegations made to authorities seeking them.

More on this topic

Museum waxes lyrical about effect of pope’s visit to IrelandMuseum waxes lyrical about effect of pope’s visit to Ireland

Pope blamed for drop in Dublin Zoo visitor numbersPope blamed for drop in Dublin Zoo visitor numbers

Pope Francis blamed for fall in visitors to Dublin ZooPope Francis blamed for fall in visitors to Dublin Zoo

PAC to review spend on luxury toilets for papal visitPAC to review spend on luxury toilets for papal visit

More in this Section

First longer Luas tram up and running on Green LineFirst longer Luas tram up and running on Green Line

Beef talks paused due to protestorsBeef talks paused due to protestors

Compensating victims of historic abuse in the North ‘remains a big priority’Compensating victims of historic abuse in the North ‘remains a big priority’

Don't succumb to the narrative of fear: Priest hits out at growing opposition to asylum seekersDon't succumb to the narrative of fear: Priest hits out at growing opposition to asylum seekers


Fiann Ó Nualláin follows in the footsteps of the Fianna as he explores a province’s hills and vales.Munster marvels: Plants that are unique to a province

Cupid must be something of a motoring enthusiast, as he had most definitely steered his way in the neighbourhood when Amie Gould and Shane O’Neill met at the Rally of the Lakes 12 years ago.Wedding of the Week: Cupid steers couple to right track

When it comes to podcasting, all it takes is one idea — and who knows where it can take you.Podcast Corner: Crimes and creatures rule at Cork’s first podcast fest

Claymation meets science fiction in this enchanting film, writes Esther McCarthy.Latest Shaun adventure is out of this world

More From The Irish Examiner