Latest: Breastcheck boss says judge's comments on screening services are a cause for concern

Latest: Breastcheck boss says judge's comments on screening services are a cause for concern
File photo

Update 8.45am: The lead clinical director of Breastcheck, the country’s breast cancer screening service, says that comments by a judge in relation to screening services are a cause for concern.

Judge Kevin Cross this week said that screeners should not give the all clear unless they have "absolute confidence" that a sample is clear.

Anne O'Doherty told Newstalk Breakfast that the public needs to have absolute confidence in all screening programmes, but they also need to realise that no screening service is 100% accurate.

“There are inherent failure rates. We will miss two in every 1,000 screenings.”

She said that no matter how good the service and its equipment or the training of the staff, a small number of cases will be due to human error.

There will be a failure rate as there isn’t a perfect system, she said.

We can’t detect all cancers. Our goal is to reduce the number of women dying.

Ms O’Doherty, who is a consultant radiologist, pointed out that one of the central aspects of any screening programme is that screening has to be cost-effective.

If the cost of screening and litigation makes it not economical then the money should be spent on helping people who are already diagnosed.

“We need to make sure the public understands the limits of screening.”

She warned that the service will not be able to recruit radiologists if there is a fear of litigation. “People go into medicine to help people, not with the intent of spending weeks and weeks in the courts.”

It is not possible to have any screening service that would offer ‘absolute confidence’ in diagnosing any disease, she added.

Earlier: Senior HSE staff propose halting screening programmes

Latest: Breastcheck boss says judge's comments on screening services are a cause for concern

Update 7.54am: Senior health service staff this week proposed halting all four of the State's screening programmes.

The proposal was made in response to last week's High Court Judgement in the Ruth Morrissey case.

The call to halt the service was made at a meeting of clinicians and HSE management last week, who met to consider the implications of the ruling in the case.

Ruth Morrisey, a terminally ill woman who had her smear test results misread, was awarded €2.1m in the High Court last week.

The Irish Times reports that there is a serious concern that the ruling could double the €30m running cost of the cervical check programme, based on the litigation costs arising from additional cases.

The main concern of among practitioners relates to the judge's declaration that screeners must have "absolute confidence" that there are no abnormalities on a slide before giving it the all clear.

There is a fear this would result in more patients being referred for additional unnecessary tests and procedures being carried out on patients that don't have cancer.

Digital Desk

More on this topic

Harris to meet social media firms to stop 'downright lies' by anti-vaccination groupsHarris to meet social media firms to stop 'downright lies' by anti-vaccination groups

#ThankYouLaura: A 'bittersweet day' for family of Laura Brennan as HPV vaccine extended to boys#ThankYouLaura: A 'bittersweet day' for family of Laura Brennan as HPV vaccine extended to boys

Irish don’t understand HPV, says researchIrish don’t understand HPV, says research

Hopefully 'putting women first' will mean receiving test results in a timely mannerHopefully 'putting women first' will mean receiving test results in a timely manner


More in this Section

Deal creating EU border in Irish Sea closerDeal creating EU border in Irish Sea closer

The key players in the UK’s hunt for a Brexit dealThe key players in the UK’s hunt for a Brexit deal

Talk of Northern Ireland-only backstop off the mark – Arlene FosterTalk of Northern Ireland-only backstop off the mark – Arlene Foster

Limerick IT and Athlone IT forming consortium to develop Technological UniversityLimerick IT and Athlone IT forming consortium to develop Technological University


Lifestyle

I am dating a lovely guy. However, he seems really awkward about being naked in front of me.Sex File: Boyfriend keeps his T-shirt on during sex

To instantly power up your look, veer towards the hard shoulder.Bold shoulder: How to instantly power up your look

Plums are a wonderful autumn fruit, useful for all sorts of recipes both sweet and savoury. In Ireland we are blessed with wonderfully sweet plums.Currabinny Cooks: Juicy plums work for both sweet and savoury dishes

The rise of home skincare devices doesn't mean that salons and clinics no longer serve a purpose.The Skin Nerd: Don’t try this at home — new treatments in the salon

More From The Irish Examiner