Jail for Limerick woman who punched disabled man in the face

Jail for Limerick woman who punched disabled man in the face

A Limerick woman with 102 previous convictions, who punched a disabled man in the face and robbed his wallet, has been jailed for three years, writes David Raleigh.

Belinda O'Sullivan told her victim, a wheelchair user, that she was helping him close his shoelaces when she carried out the "despicable" crime, Limerick Circuit Court heard today.

Evidence of the "cowardly" crime was read into the record by presiding judge, Tom O'Donnell, at O'Sullivan's sentencing hearing.

Judge O'Donnell also outlined how O'Sullivan has lived a sad and "chaotic" life since she was a child.

The court heard she had sunk into a "downward spiral" of drug addiction resulting from a particularly "difficult upbringing".

O'Sullivan's victim, a man in his 20s, who has cerebral palsy, and is a wheelchair user, was approached by the defendant and an accomplice, on Lord Edward Street, on May 25, 2014.

It was the day before O'Sullivan's 24th birthday, and she was looking to rob money to buy drugs.

She knew her victim, the court heard, and tricked him into making him believe she was tying his shoelaces when she robbed his wallet, that contained €80 cash.

"The victim hit the accused to protect himself and when he lashed out, the accused struck him in the face," the judge said.

"When gardaí found him he was in a distressed state and they had to call a specially trained garda and a disability advocate," the judge added.

In a victim impact statement the victim said, in his opinion, he was targeted because he was "seen as an easy target because of his disability".

He said he was "slowly building up his confidence" following the incident.

Judge O'Donnell said the man "gave gardaí an excellent account of what happened" and he "deserves enormous credit for helping gardaí to solve the crime".

It was heard that from an early age O'Sullivan had become addicted to drugs after suffering a "difficult childhood".

She herself was "a victim of violence in relationships" the judge said.

"She leads a chaotic lifestyle and has, through her addictions been rendered homeless on many occasions."

O'Sullivan had made attempts to tackle her drug abuse and childhood traumas but had always "relapsed into drug use and criminality".

"She has made attempts at self-harm because of her difficult childhood," the judge added.

He said O'Sullivan "expressed sincere remorse" about robbing her vulnerable victim and, despite her crimes was, "well-intentioned but (always) reverts to type".

The judge described the robbery as an "appalling incident".

"She stooped so low as to take advantage of a disabled man in broad daylight."

"It was cowardly and despicable."

He added: "Despite serving past short sentences, she still commits crime."

At the time she robbed the man, O'Sullivan was on bail on two separate Section 99 suspended sentence orders, one for threatening to kill a serving garda, the other for robbery.

Judge O'Donnell made no order on the suspended sentences.

If the court had activated the Section 99 orders, O'Sullivan would have been sentenced to six years jail instead of three years.

"In view of her guilty plea, and her remorse, I have decided not to (activate) any of the suspended sentences at this time," the judge said.

He noted a probation report, dated last February, which had been canvassed by the judge, stated..."the accused needs some respite to break the downward spiral she's on, to help her develop coping skills and cope with her addiction problems."

O'Sullivan also pleaded guilty to robbing €39.14 worth of hair and beauty products from a hair salon, on July 2, 2014, while she was on bail.

O'Sullivan carried out the robberies while she was on consecutive suspended sentences for robbery; threatening to kill a garda, assaulting the same officer, and possessing an imitation firearm during the same incident.

On December 19, 2013, O'Sullivan was given a one-year jail sentence, suspended for four years.

At the time she pleaded guilty to threatening to kill Garda Gavin Fisher, assaulting Gda Fisher, and using an imitation gun while threatening the officer, at the Travelodge hotel, Coonagh, Limerick, on July 16, 2012.

She received a consecutive two-year suspended sentence on the same date after pleading guilty to robbing two men of a mobile phone, and €50 cash, on October 11, 2010.

O'Sullivan had accumulated 102 convictions when she targeted the man.

Judge O'Donnell described O'Sullivan's criminal record as "appalling".

O'Sullivan's barrister said: "Various agencies including the Simon Community are prepared to offer her a safety net" after she serves her sentence.

The judge remarked he hoped O'Sullivan would be rehabilitated.


More in this Section

Taoiseach defends Govt's handling of flood defences as flood-hit counties await further rainTaoiseach defends Govt's handling of flood defences as flood-hit counties await further rain

Snow and ice forecast for the whole country tomorrowSnow and ice forecast for the whole country tomorrow

Carer who stole €41k from grieving pensioner gets suspended sentence in order to pay it backCarer who stole €41k from grieving pensioner gets suspended sentence in order to pay it back

Supreme Court's referral of Dwyer data-retention case 'has important implications for investigation of serious crime'Supreme Court's referral of Dwyer data-retention case 'has important implications for investigation of serious crime'


Lifestyle

Children’s creativity is inspiring, says Helen O’Callaghan.Inspiring creativity: Kids on call for climate essay

'I came here for one thing, and that's to shine. That's why I'm wearing all this sparkly shit.'Review: Mick Flannery and Valerie June, Right Here Right Now festival, Cork Opera House

While love was in the air earlier this month, An Garda Síochána has warned daters of the potential dangers of looking for love online.Making Cents: Online daters can risk more than just their heart

It’s natural to worry if your kids keep picking up colds and tummy bugs at nursery or school.Can I prevent my children getting sick so often?

More From The Irish Examiner