Greater legal protection from 'sexual stereotypes' needed during rape trials: Ivana Bacik

Greater legal protection from 'sexual stereotypes' needed during rape trials: Ivana Bacik

Alleged rape victims must be given greater legal protection during trials to ensure "sexual stereotypes" such as what underwear a woman wears are prevented from being raised.

Labour senator Ivana Bacik said the reforms are needed as a result of the Belfast rugby players rape trial and the recent case of a young woman's underwear being raised as evidence during a recent trial in the Republic.

Speaking to reporters in Leinster House, Ms Bacik said she supports recommended changes in the Northern Ireland courts system to ensure rape cases are held behind-closed-doors or "in camera" to prevent the "horrific sort of trial by entertainment" during the Belfast rugby rape trial.

While the in camera model already exists in the Republic, Ms Bacik said further changes may also be needed in this jurisdiction, saying there are genuine concerns about how rape trials currently operate.

Ms Bacik - who has been Reid professor of criminal law, criminology and penology at Trinity college's law school since 1996 - declined to comment on any specific case when asked if she was concerned about the recent case of a young woman's underwear being shown as evidence during a rape trial in the Republic.

However, noting the legitimate public anger over the way in which alleged rape victims are treated during at times confrontational court hearings, the Labour senator said changes are now needed.

"Tom O Malley is chairing a departmental review due to report to the Irish Government in December, I will be feeding into that review, and my Labour colleagues including Sean Sherlock are drafting legislating to deal specifically saying they should discount sexual stereotypes.

Without commenting on any specific case, clearly reports [of recent cases] would be a concern, and I and others are hugely concerned this would become an issue in jury deliberations.

"One of the things I'll be saying is ensuring complainants have more legal support throughout the trial," Ms Bacik said.

Asked about the Belfast rugby players rape trial and similar changes taking place in response to how the cross-examination of the alleged victim was approached, Ms Bacik added:

"I am certainly supportive of the recommendation of in camera cases [for Northern Ireland], it is well established here in Ireland.

"Members of the public would not have been permitted into the courtroom here in the Republic, we would not have seen the horrific sort of trial by entertainment that we did see in the courtroom, to the distress of the complainant, the family of the complainant and indeed the defendants."

More on this topic

Dublin Rape Crisis Centre calls for more state funding to deal with sexual violence ‘epidemic’Dublin Rape Crisis Centre calls for more state funding to deal with sexual violence ‘epidemic’

Ireland ‘in grip of sexual violence crisis’; Rape Crisis Centre sees demand for services soarIreland ‘in grip of sexual violence crisis’; Rape Crisis Centre sees demand for services soar

Rape cases increased by almost 80% since 2014Rape cases increased by almost 80% since 2014

Taxi driver case prompts concerns over enforceability of bail conditions in sexual offence casesTaxi driver case prompts concerns over enforceability of bail conditions in sexual offence cases

More in this Section

Project diverting youths from drugs and gangs facing axeProject diverting youths from drugs and gangs facing axe

Ireland sees 43% fall in the numbers of children adopted from abroad since 2013Ireland sees 43% fall in the numbers of children adopted from abroad since 2013

Airport security worker sues Dublin Airport Authority over fall from truckAirport security worker sues Dublin Airport Authority over fall from truck

MP: Same-sex marriage change enjoys overwhelming support in Northern IrelandMP: Same-sex marriage change enjoys overwhelming support in Northern Ireland


Lifestyle

A topic I find myself discussing a lot in the therapeutic space is that of shouting. Of course, we all raise our voices from time to time when dealing with our children.Learning Points: Shouting drowns out the message you want heard

Róisín O is one half of Thanks Brother with John Broe.A Question of Taste: Róisín O

Keen to boost her borders without breaking the bank, Hannah Stephenson consults Mark Gregory of Channel 5’s ‘The Great Gardening Challenge’.Gardening on a budget? We'll show you how

More From The Irish Examiner