Gardaí 'pushed' for Ian Bailey case

Gardaí 'pushed' for Ian Bailey case

A former Garda inspector pushed for a harassment case against Ian Bailey despite concerns it would be difficult to prosecute, he has told a court.

Retired Vincent Duggan, who was stationed at Bantry, Co Cork, said he was told to investigate a number of allegations by witness Marie Farrell in 1997.

Mr Bailey, 57, an Englishman who moved to West Cork more than 23 years ago, is suing the State after being arrested twice over the killing of a French film producer.

Sophie Toscan du Plantier, 39, was found beaten to death outside her home in West Cork on December 23, 1996.

Mr Bailey denies any involvement in the death and was never charged.

Dublin’s High Court heard Ms Farrell alleged she had been approached by Mr Bailey at her shop in Schull on June 30 1997 and was left most upset by the encounter.

Mr Duggan said he went to the village to speak with Mr Bailey about the claims, but the law graduate and former journalist said he had just called into the shop for a coffee.

The retired inspector said Mr Bailey agreed that Ms Farrell be left in peace.

Under cross-examination, he said he was not told at the time the encounter in the shop was being recorded by gardai, in what Mr Bailey’s legal team described as a staged event.

Later that year, on December 19 Ms Farrell contacted gardai again complaining she had received an upsetting phone call that day from Mr Bailey.

Mr Duggan said he was instructed to take a statement from her and prepare a file on the incidents.

On meeting Mr Bailey to put the allegations to him, he was told that he was in Bantry the day of the alleged phone call and never made any calls.

A garda sergeant in Bantry confirmed seeing Mr Bailey in the town on the day and no telephone call could be traced, he told the court.

Mr Duggan said in his file on the harassment allegations, he recommended “with a caveat” the Director of Public Prosecutions proceed with a case against Mr Bailey.

The decision was taken based on the “totality” of the allegations and it was not unusual to express views, doubts and possible difficulties when recommending prosecution, he said.

In the event, the public prosecutor decided not to go ahead with any proceedings.

Judge John Hedigan told the jury there were 32 witnesses left in the long-running case.

“I think there’s a bit of light at the end of the tunnel, I can see the end approaching,” he said.

It is expected the hearings could be completed by the end of March or beginning of April.

More on this topic

State needs time to consider Ian Bailey’s objections to French extradition, court toldState needs time to consider Ian Bailey’s objections to French extradition, court told

Ian Bailey appears in Dublin court in relation to extradition bidIan Bailey appears in Dublin court in relation to extradition bid

Michael Clifford: Is Irish criminal justice now on trial?Michael Clifford: Is Irish criminal justice now on trial?

Judge hands back translated Ian Bailey murder judgement because of continuing 'translation issues'Judge hands back translated Ian Bailey murder judgement because of continuing 'translation issues'


More in this Section

Coronavirus: Restrictions on movement to remain in place for Northern IrelandCoronavirus: Restrictions on movement to remain in place for Northern Ireland

Dr Tony Holohan reiterates call for those awaiting Covid-19 test results to remain in isolationDr Tony Holohan reiterates call for those awaiting Covid-19 test results to remain in isolation

One-off use of Dublin Convention Centre to sit Dáil to cost €160kOne-off use of Dublin Convention Centre to sit Dáil to cost €160k

Reports of Dubliners 'flocking' to beaches in Mayo and Wexford led to signing of emergency lawsReports of Dubliners 'flocking' to beaches in Mayo and Wexford led to signing of emergency laws


Lifestyle

Junior Cert and Leaving Cert students mustn’t be forced to go through the motions with state exams, and we need creative thinking to find alternatives fast, writes mother and educator Ellie O’Byrne.Policy fail? Insistence that state exams go ahead in June is glib and ignorant

Yes, we all need to stay at home but that doesn't mean your children have to be bored, says Michelle McGlynnWorld of wonder: What to do with the children outdoors

Over the next three weeks, I am going to outline how you can support yourself and your family over this period of lockdown, writes Richard Hogan.Learning Points: Keeping children on a healthy and happy regime

As we are settling into our new routines of self isolation, staying at home and home schooling it feels that a whole new set of pressures is coming down the tracks.Mum's The Word: Pressure to be productive in a world of online classes

More From The Irish Examiner