Garda Commissioner’s evidence over prosecution of civilian employee raises questions

Garda Commissioner Drew Harris

The evidence of Garda Commissioner Drew Harris before the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) earlier this month about the controversial prosecution of a civilian Garda employee, has raised some serious questions.

An investigation of the commissioner’s answers, and responses from the Garda Press Office, about the Margiotta case suggest that Mr Harris may have inadvertently given the wrong impression about aspects of the case.

The trial of Lynn Margiotta and her GP brother, Tony, for producing false sick notes, collapsed at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court on March 26.

Ms Margiotta is a civilian employee of An Garda Síochána. Dr Margiotta was accused of providing her with sick notes that were not authentic in 2014, even though gardaí accepted that Ms Margiotta had a medical condition.

Both siblings denied there was anything untoward about how Ms Margiotta acquired the sick notes. 

Both claim the case was motivated by a bullying complaint Ms Margiotta made against a Garda three weeks before she was first arrested in August 2014.

Lynn Margiotta
Lynn Margiotta

In evidence at the PAC on May 9, Mr Harris said there was no record of a bullying complaint in the case.

“None can be found,” he told David Cullinane TD.

However, the Irish Examiner has learned that Ms Margiotta did make a verbal complaint, setting in train a process that would lead to a formal written complaint.

As per public sector policy, there was due to be a meeting to attempt mediation in the issue, but before the meeting could take place, she was arrested over the alleged false sick notes.

This information was conveyed to the Garda Press Office on Monday, for a response in relation to Mr Harris’ evidence, but no response was given.

Separately, the commissioner also appeared to give the PAC the impression that the case was being investigated by the Garda Ombudsman (Gsoc).

David Cullinane
David Cullinane

Mr Cullinane asked the commissioner if he was of a mind to “personally examine the elements of the case that are in the public domain”.

The commissioner responded: “That is also the subject of a public complaint to Gsoc. The material we are putting together is for its information and I have to wait for it to make its recommendations.”

According to a spokesperson, Gsoc is not currently investigating any aspect of the case that it understands was being referred to at the PAC.

In response to a question on this matter, the Garda Press Office replied that the commissioner was referring to a complaint from 2016.

In fact, the 2016 complaint, a copy of which has been seen by the Irish Examiner, referred to leaks to the media about Ms Margiotta’s arrest. 

This was completed without resolution by Gsoc in November 2017.

2014-2019: Sick notes case timeline

January – July 2014

Lynn Margiotta is absent from work on a number of occasions following the death of her mother.

She had worked as a civilian employee in An Garda Síochána in Store St station in Dublin since 1999.

Gardaí accept that she was suffering from a medical condition during this period.

July 24, 2014

Lynn Margiotta makes a complaint of bullying against a garda member. This is made verbally at first as per policy.

July 23-30, 2014

Arrangements are put in train to deal with the bullying complaint through the Dignity in Work policy for public servants.

A meeting of union and management is postponed because of holiday arrangements.

August 11, 2014

Lynn Margiotta is arrested at her home in Navan by guards from Store St.

She is interviewed about sick notes which had been signed by her brother, Dr Tony Margiotta.

She is interviewed without a solicitor being present. The main evidence the gardaí were working off was that a number of sick notes signed by Dr Margiotta bore the stamp of two other GPs.

The process to deal with her complaint of bullying is not continued.

February 11, 2015

Professor Colin Bradley of UCC delivers a report on GP policy and working arrangements in the use of professional stamps.

June – July 2015

Dr Tony Margiotta is interviewed four times under caution about the “sick notes”.

He freely admitted that he signed the notes on the basis of his sister’s medical condition.

Other GPs had signed similar notes on other occasions for Lynn Margiotta.

He tells gardaí there was nothing unusual in using a colleague’s stamp.

September 18, 2015

Lynn Margiotta is arrested for a second time. A report in the Herald on that day quotes a source as saying this is a “lengthy investigation” into “fake sick certs”.

The source was also quoted as saying: “She was putting in for sick certs on days that it is suspected she was not sick at all.”

This is in conflict with evidence at the subsequent criminal trial which was told by the investigating garda that he believed she was sick at the time.

June 10, 2017

Lynn and Tony Margiotta are arrested at their homes without notice at 8am to be charged.

The date was a Saturday. Usually charges brought on a Saturday would relate to extradition, executing warrants, or violent or fatal crime.

July 2017

The solicitors for the siblings are made aware that the DPP would agree to the case being dealt with by the district court if the defendants plead guilty.

If they contest the charges the case will go to the Circuit Criminal Court, greatly raising the prospect of a prison sentence in the event of conviction.

The prosecution is obliged to discover all relevant evidence to the defence at this juncture. The Bradley report is not discovered.

It is unclear if the DPP was in possession of the report. The siblings opt to go for trial at the circuit court.

February 6, 2019

Defence solicitors receive the Bradley report in discovery for the trial.

If the defendants had pleaded guilty there is no reason to believe the Bradley report would ever have surfaced.

March 14, 2019

The trial opens in Dublin Circuit Criminal Court.

Most of the remainder of the trial is a voir dire, effectively a trial within a trial in the absence of the jury to determine if particular evidence should be admitted.

March 26, 2019

The trial collapses after Judge Patricia Ryan rules that Lynn Margiotta was denied the right to a solicitor while under arrest and her privacy had been breached by accessing her medical records without her consent or a warrant.

After four and a half years Lynn and Tony Margiotta finally have the cloud of a criminal conviction and possible prison sentence lifted.

March 26 – Present

Lynn Margiotta has not been formally contacted by her employer despite the end of the criminal proceedings.

For most of the last four and a half years she was without an income.

More on this topic

GRA: Armed units not a long term solution in Longford

Garda takes his own life after child abuse probe

Gardaí: Posting holiday snaps could act as 'advertisement' to burglars

New deputy Garda Commissioner to be appointed

More in this Section

70% of people in UK believe gay couples should be able to marry in NI

Major flaw in laws prohibiting resale of NAMA properties to developers revealed

Technical group established to look at Brexit backstop alternatives

GRA: Armed units not a long term solution in Longford


Lifestyle

Pop-up gardens show off the best of the Ancient East

Ask Audrey: I keep having filthy thoughts about boy-racer types from West Kerry

The history of eyelashes: The tiny hairs that hold huge sway in the beauty industry

Garry Ringrose on playing the long game

More From The Irish Examiner