Female manager whose boss said she had 'beautiful eyes' awarded €4,000 for harassment

By Gordon Deegan

A female service station manager was harassed on the grounds of gender after her married boss told that she had "beautiful eyes" and criticised her management approach.

In the case, the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) has ordered the un-named service station business to pay its former manager €4,000 compensation over the harassment.

Female manager whose boss said she had 'beautiful eyes' awarded €4,000 for harassment

The woman successfully claimed harassment on the grounds of gender as a result of a site visit by the business’s area manager to the service station on July 8, 2016.

The woman told the WRC hearing that the way her area manager spoke to and behaved towards her on that date “left her feeling humiliated and undermined”.

She said that her boss made inappropriate comments in relation to how she performed in her role, namely questioning her method of invoicing, criticising the store layout, suggesting she should take a “step down” and threatening her with disciplinary action if she refused.

He also told her that the staff had no respect for her. During the same encounter, the area manager also told his colleague “that she had beautiful eyes”.

The service station manager made an internal complaint on the area manager’s overall comments and in an email to the company’s Human Resources (HR) department, the area manager accepted that he had commented on the woman’s eyes.

In his findings, WRC Adjudication Officer, Andrew Heavey stated: “I find that, within the context and tone of that conversations during the site visit, the complainant was justified in feeling uncomfortable with that remark.”

Mr Heavey said that he was satisfied “that the conduct of the area manager towards the complainant was harassing in nature” on July 8, 2016.

Mr Heavey said that the area manager made references to his own wife and her personality traits when discussing the complainant’s management style.

He said: “On that basis, I find that the complainant’s gender was a significant factor in the area manager's attitude towards her.”

The woman had separately claimed that the comment on her eyes amounted to sexual harassment but Mr Heavey said that he did not find that the man’s comments were sexual in nature and did not find that the woman was the subject of sexual harassment.

However, Mr Heavey said that the area manager behaved in a way that was “unsupportive and dismissive of the complainant which left her feeling humiliated and demeaned”.

He said: “I also find that his attitude towards her was one of criticism as opposed to one of support and assistance.”

According to Mr Heavey, the area manager accepted that he made the comment about his colleague’s eyes but denied much else of what he was accused of having said.”

Mr Heavey said that the attitude of the area manager towards the complainant was “inappropriate” on July 8, 2016.

The service station manager resigned with immediate effect on January 27, 2017.

However, Mr Heavey found that the woman’s claim for constructive dismissal was not well founded after finding that the employer did not behave in such a way that left the woman with no option but to resign.

More on this topic

Dublin Airport police officer loses unfair dismissal case over being sacked for wrongly claiming €250 in lost propertyDublin Airport police officer loses unfair dismissal case over being sacked for wrongly claiming €250 in lost property

Care worker fired for allegedly striking patient awarded €15k after home fails to follow dismissal protocolsCare worker fired for allegedly striking patient awarded €15k after home fails to follow dismissal protocols

€30,000 award for catering assistant who suffered sexual harassment at hands of chef/manager€30,000 award for catering assistant who suffered sexual harassment at hands of chef/manager

Irish Rail signal man fired after failing drugs test loses unfair dismissal caseIrish Rail signal man fired after failing drugs test loses unfair dismissal case


More in this Section

NI mother prosecuted for buying abortion pills for teen daughter is formally acquittedNI mother prosecuted for buying abortion pills for teen daughter is formally acquitted

Trolley watch figure rises above 550Trolley watch figure rises above 550

Boy, 11, whose service dog won award now fighting cancerBoy, 11, whose service dog won award now fighting cancer

Report reveals rise in number of young children suffering from anorexiaReport reveals rise in number of young children suffering from anorexia


Lifestyle

Steak night just got zingy.How to make Antoni Porowski’s hanger steak with charred limes, fresh chillies and herbs

Seasonal affective disorder is a lot more complex than just mourning the end of summer and being a bit glum. Liz Connor finds out more.Could your winter blues be something more serious? What to do if you’re worried about SAD

Ideal for a quick mid-week meal, eaten in front of Netflix, of course.How to make Antoni Porowski’s cauliflower steaks with turmeric and crunchy almonds

Lacemakers in Limerick want to preserve their unique craft for future generations and hope to gain UNESCO heritage status, writes Ellie O’Byrne.Made in Munster: Lace-making a labour of love rather than laborious industry

More From The Irish Examiner