External auditors gave 'clean opinion' on end-of-year accounts, former Anglo banker tells David Drumm trial

External auditors gave 'clean opinion' on end-of-year accounts, former Anglo banker tells David Drumm trial
David Drumm.

A former Anglo Irish banker said external auditors gave “a clean opinion” on the bank's end-of-year accounts when they were published in December 2008.

Kevin Kelly agreed with lawyers for the bank's former CEO David Drumm (aged 51) that auditors Ernst & Young could have chosen to give “a qualified opinion” regarding the bank's financial health.

“There's a third option they could have gone for when signing off, but they gave a clean opinion. They said the accounts were a true and fair view of the bank's financial position,” he said.

Mr Drumm of Skerries, Co Dublin, has pleaded not guilty to conspiring with former bank officials Denis Casey, William McAteer, John Bowe and others to defraud depositors and investors at Anglo by “dishonestly” creating the impression that deposits in 2008 were €7.2 billion larger than they were.

He has also pleaded not guilty to false accounting on December 3, 2008, by furnishing information to the market that Anglo's 2008 deposits were €7.2 billion larger than they were.

Mr Drumm accepts that multi-million-euro transactions took place between Anglo and Irish Life & Permanent (ILP) in 2008, but disputes that they were fraudulent or dishonest.

Today on day 43 of the trial at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court, Mr Kelly, who was described as “an accountant of some experience”, said an Ernst & Young audit team moved into Anglo headquarters to carry out the audit in November 2008.

“We had shared a lot of information with our auditors prior to them coming on site,” he said.

He agreed with Bernard Condon SC, defending, that the fact Anglo's transactions with Irish Life & Permanent (ILP) were settled gross didn't change “the accounting treatment of it”.

When asked about inaccuracies in the document regarding the description of the transactions, he said it was a surprise when he found out in early 2009 that the deal had “settled net”.

“I was told they were settled gross,” he said.

He said he wasn't sure who had told him this, and added it could have been a misunderstanding “on our side or on someone else's side”.

Previously in the trial, Anglo banker Colm Golden said that the head of Ernst & Young's audit team, Vincent Bergin, shrugged his shoulders and described the transactions with ILP as “technically sound”.

Mr Kelly told Paul O'Higgins SC, prosecuting, that he didn't know about the transactions with ILP until 2009, when two Anglo executives gave him “a broad outline and mentioned the €7bn”.

He said he was told the transaction was settled gross, with no available legal right of set off.

When asked how large the transactions were in the general scheme of things at Anglo, he said they were “quite significant”.

The trial, which began eight weeks ago, continues before Judge Karen O'Connor and a jury of 10 men and four women.

More on this topic

Major setback for Seann Quinn's children in €410m liability caseMajor setback for Seann Quinn's children in €410m liability case

Official who shredded key papers to explain decisionOfficial who shredded key papers to explain decision

'Is it more of the roll-over over Leo?' - SF reacts to €270m Anglo payout to junior bondholders'Is it more of the roll-over over Leo?' - SF reacts to €270m Anglo payout to junior bondholders

Irish Banking Resolution Corporation still party to 138 legal actionsIrish Banking Resolution Corporation still party to 138 legal actions

More in this Section

Ireland 'cannot do a side deal' with the UK, says CoveneyIreland 'cannot do a side deal' with the UK, says Coveney

Gardaí very concerned for welfare of woman, 64, missing from DublinGardaí very concerned for welfare of woman, 64, missing from Dublin

515 patients waiting for beds in Irish hospitals515 patients waiting for beds in Irish hospitals

Irish mum in US horrified at 'bullet-proof' schoolbagsIrish mum in US horrified at 'bullet-proof' schoolbags


Lifestyle

We have two words for you: tiny sunglasses.6 of the biggest fashion trends from The Matrix as a fourth movie is announced

With more than 70 museums, 30 parks and a maze of canals, this city is a giant playground, says Kirsty Masterman.Bikes, boats and pancakes: Why Amsterdam is the new go-to destination for family-friendly travel

It’s 100% better than takeout.How to make Jamie Oliver’s veggie pad thai

The Hunger is billed as an opera, but its composer, Donnacha Dennehy, prefers to call it a “docu-cantata”.The Hunger: Appeals to God and for pity in this clash of two linguistic worlds

More From The Irish Examiner