Woman receives suspended six-month jail term for stealing from ‘fragile and emotionally distressed' 84-year-old

By Gordon Deegan

A thieving home-help who was stealing from a "fragile and emotionally distressed" 84-year-old woman was caught after secret cameras were installed in her home.

In a bid to catch the suspected thief, two secret cameras were installed at the home of Peggy O’Grady after she raised concerns with him over missing monies at her rural home near Scarriff.

The secret cameras were installed to watch over Mrs O’Grady’s safe and her handbag and caught Clarecare home help, Mary Doyle in the act of stealing €220 on five separate occasions in April of last year.

At Ennis District Court today, Det. Garda Bernard Casey said that Ms Doyle (55) of Ross, Feakle in east Clare denied the thieving in a Garda interview until she was presented with the video evidence from the two secret cameras

Det. Casey said that a number of different home helps were aiding Mrs O’Grady and that over a 24-day period in April 2017, the concealed cameras filmed Ms Doyle taking money from Mrs O’Grady’s handbag on four occasions and going to the safe and taking a quantity of cash.

He said: “As a result of that I arrested the defendant on 3rd of May 2017.”

Prior to the cameras being installed, Det. Casey said that Mrs O’Grady believed there was money missing from two areas - from a safe in her bedroom and a purse in a handbag in a press in her kitchen.

Imposing a suspended six-month jail term on Ms Doyle for stealing the €220 from the widow on five separate dates, Judge Patrick Durcan said that one of the aggravating factors was Ms Doyle brazening it out and denying the thefts before she was presented with the video footage.

Judge Durcan said that Mrs O’Grady had lost her husband only months prior in August 2017 and she was at the time of the thefts “fragile, aged and emotionally distressed”.

Judge Durcan said that Ms Doyle “was entrusted with care and welfare of short periods of time of an elderly lady living in a rural area and she flagrantly breached that trust”.

He said that Ms Doyle “interfered with the private personal savings of Mrs Peggy O’Grady and removed monies from her handbag and monies from a safe. That is the greatest aggravating factor.”

Judge Durcan said that what had taken place “was at the upper end of this type of criminality”.

Solicitor for Ms Doyle, Turlough Herbert said that his client admitted that the offences are “despicable”.

He said: “By any standards, it is a serious betrayal of trust to a vulnerable person and she apologises unreservedly to Ms O’Grady for that.”

Insp. Tom Kennedy said that Mrs O’Grady has been fully compensated.

Mr Herbert said that Ms Doyle’s crime has brought much embarrassment to her “and she has been very much ostracised”.

Mr Herbert said that Ms Doyle has had serious health difficulties. He said: “She got on quite well with clients and she was well liked.”

Mr Herbert said that Ms Doyle has “two sons who have done quite well in life”.

He said: “This has been very difficult for her and her family and she has destroyed any prospect of further employment.”

Det. Casey said that Ms Doyle “comes from a good background and well liked by clientele that she dealt with in her job”.


Related Articles

Murder trial hears how witness gave the Act of Contrition to a man who had been struck by car and attacked

Cork man who killed mother to 'set her free' from the cruelty of life convicted of murder

TD asked political secretary to oversee £250,000 payment, Lowry trial told

Court asked to hear appeal with possible implications for up to 1,000 'slopping out' cases.

More in this Section

First wrongful birth case to be heard in Irish courts settled with interim payout of €1.8m

Epileptic boy must not become victim of Northern Ireland’s silence, says MP

Lawyers appeal for leniency as sentencing hearing of former Anglo chief David Drumm begins

Social Democrat TDs withdraw from MacGill Summer School over male-dominated panels


Today's Stories

Switch could save 27,000 mortgage holders €10k

Ombudsman report: ‘Lack of sensitivity’ in teen psych units

Bad Wolves raises €250k for O’Riordan’s children

HSE urged to release contracts of US smear test labs

Lifestyle

New father’s life ‘changed forever’ after he was run over by surgeon

More From The Irish Examiner