Donohoe defends decision to overrule concerns over €3bn National Broadband Plan cost

Donohoe defends decision to overrule concerns over €3bn National Broadband Plan cost

Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe has defended his decision to overrule concerns expressed by his senior officials over the cost of the €3bn National Broadband Plan.

He said on balance it is appropriate to proceed with the plan notwithstanding the concerns raised.

Mr Donohoe said he had to consider the cost of the project versus the cost of scrapping it and starting again and said it was best to proceed.

He said he "deeply" wrestled with this decision saying he has been at the heart of the decision for many months.

Cabinet ministers were warned by senior spending officials that proceeding with the National Broadband Plan would constitute a “breach of the public spending code”.

In memos, given to ministers in advance of their decision to approve the €3 billion plan, officials warned that the project failed a value for money examination and it represented a potential threat to the financial well-being of the State.

Written observations included in a confidential cabinet memo shared with ministers, senior department officials warned that other public capital projects, including roads and social housing would have to be postponed or cancelled to pay for the costs of the broadband plan.

Donohoe defends decision to overrule concerns over €3bn National Broadband Plan cost

The warnings were sent by senior officials in Public Expenditure Minister Paschal Donohoe's department, including its secretary general Robert Watt.

The documents also show that Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe's ministerial colleagues were also told that cheaper alternatives were available.

Ultimately, Mr Donohoe disagreed with those concerns and recommended that the Government go ahead with the project.

On balance, the decision I have made to on balance to go ahead with the project relates to the many issues I have touched upon about the future of our economy.

Earlier this morning the secretary general of the Department of Public Expenditure Robert Watt declined to comment on his advice about the plan at a public event.

More on this topic

Minister to consider findings of scathing broadband reportMinister to consider findings of scathing broadband report

Northern Ireland in the running for rural 5G trialsNorthern Ireland in the running for rural 5G trials

FF will not 'bring down the Government' over broadband planFF will not 'bring down the Government' over broadband plan

Isolated houses could pay more for broadbandIsolated houses could pay more for broadband


More in this Section

Homecoming date for victorious Dublin footballers announced Homecoming date for victorious Dublin footballers announced

Gardaí in Cork renew appeal for witnesses to serious assault on Patrick StGardaí in Cork renew appeal for witnesses to serious assault on Patrick St

8 minutes away from gas supply being ignited: 19 families homeless after Dublin flats fire8 minutes away from gas supply being ignited: 19 families homeless after Dublin flats fire

Man killed in early-morning Kerry collisionMan killed in early-morning Kerry collision


Lifestyle

Make-up artist Terry Barber reveals the secret to pulling off the bold lip look.This is how to make black lipstick work in real life, according to a catwalk make-up pro

Off to the Japan? After a trip to Tokyo, Ella Walker outlines the best things to eat between matches.These are the dishes to try if you’re going to Tokyo for the Rugby World Cup

It still surprises me as I am achingly private and do not enjoy being at the centre of attention.This Much I Know: Actor Aislin McGuckin

Bride Geraldine O’Donovan felt as wonderful as she looked on her big day — knowing she was supporting a cause close to her heart as she donned her wedding gown.Wedding on the Week: Supporting a cause close to their hearts

More From The Irish Examiner