Court hears accused hit victim's son before father was killed

Court hears accused hit victim's son before father was killed

A woman on trial for murdering a 66-year-old man hit his son over the head with a baseball bat shortly before the deceased was struck by a car and killed, the Central Criminal Court has heard.

Giving evidence on the opening day of the Claire Nolan murder trial, Josephine Cunningham told the court that the accused had been drinking in her house with her daughter on the night Michael Duffy was killed, and that she “probably wasn't in the right frame of mind” at the time.

Ms Cunningham described for the court how the accused thought Mr Duffy's son had been trying to steal her new car, and became involved in a row with him during which she hit him across the head.

Claire Nolan (aged 23), of Sheephill Green in Blanchardstown, has denied murdering Michael Duffy at Well View Grove in Blanchardstown, on January 26, 2008.

The retired taxi driver died after he was struck by a car in the driveway of his son, Francis Duffy's home in Blanchardstown.

He had driven there from his home in Cavan.

Ms Nolan has admitted manslaughter, but the State has refused to accept the plea.

Opening the case for the prosecution, Mr Patrick Gageby SC, told the jury that it's the State's argument that Mr Duffy's “death was attributable... to the driving of the car by Claire Nolan.”

“You will hear evidence, which I think will satisfy you, that the car was driven at some speed into the driveway, through the closed gates and right up to the house itself. And in doing that, Mr Duffy Senior was hit by the car and crushed to death,” Mr Gageby said.

Josephine Cunningham, who lives next door to the deceased's son, Francis Duffy, said she was upstairs when she heard her daughter shouting at Ms Nolan that someone was trying to steal her Nissan Micra, which was parked in the driveway of their house.

Ms Nolan had just bought the car that day.

“When Claire heard that she ran out and went and looked into the car and the radio was gone or something,” Ms Cunningham said.

She described the accused as being angry. “I suppose she was annoyed, plus she was after having a few drinks so she would have been in a rage,” the witness told the court.

She said she saw her neighbour, Francis Duffy, in his garden talking on his mobile phone, and that there was blood streaming down his face because the “outraged person” had “belted him” over the head with a bat.

When asked by Mr Gageby who the outraged person was, the witness replied “Claire”.

Ms Cunningham said she returned inside, but heard “smashing glass and the rev of a car” and on looking out the window, saw the accused's car being reversed out of her driveway, crashing through the gates of Mr Duffy's house, and being driven up his driveway.

She said she couldn't see who was driving the car at the time, but she saw her daughter's boyfriend trying to stop the car.

“(He) was standing with his hands wide open saying “stop” and “kill me”...I suppose he jumped out of the way and then Mr Duffy got it.”

Ms Cunningham said she didn't know Michael Duffy had arrived on the scene until she saw him lying in the driveway next door, with his son standing over him.

During cross examination by counsel for the defence, Mr Brendan Grehan SC, Ms Cunningham described the accused as a calm person; “I knew Claire as a placid girl...you'd never think anything like this would happen, you know.”

She also said she hadn't seen Francis Duffy smashing the window of the accused's car, nor had she seen him with a knife.

She said she didn't recall hearing her daughter's boyfriend telling the accused to leave the scene.

Ms Nolan's car was found having been set on fire in “circumstances that are not clear” about twenty minutes after the incident.

The trial resumes in the morning before Mr Justice Barry White.

More in this Section

Covid-19: One person has died and 11 new cases confirmedCovid-19: One person has died and 11 new cases confirmed

Rare beaked whale trapped in Wicklow Harbour not expected to surviveRare beaked whale trapped in Wicklow Harbour not expected to survive

Five arrested after 'violent disorder' incidents in Co WestmeathFive arrested after 'violent disorder' incidents in Co Westmeath

UUP call for 'independent inquiry' to investigate coronavirus guideline breaches at Bobby Storey funeralUUP call for 'independent inquiry' to investigate coronavirus guideline breaches at Bobby Storey funeral


Lifestyle

Cross rope bridges strung across the Atlantic or visit reimagining of time gone by; whatever you fancy doing, you’ll find it in Ulster.Staycations 2020: Take your pick from these great things to do in Ulster

I can’t eat anything without chilli flakes stuffed into itShape I'm In: Novelis Emma Murray

Peter Dowdall has advice on caring for these perennial favouritesLook after your peonies and they'll brighten your garden

A routine smear test picked up Eileen Rushe's cancer when she was in her early 30s. It was a long road to recovery, says Arlene Harris.In check: Why every woman must get a cervical screening test

More From The Irish Examiner