Counsel claims stabbing of taxi driver is 'worst-case' scenario as DPP seeks to increase man's sentence

Counsel claims stabbing of taxi driver is 'worst-case' scenario as DPP seeks to increase man's sentence
Mr Mulligan's taxi.

A man who stabbed a taxi driver and left him to die on the side of a rural road in Co. Louth must wait to hear whether his prison sentence will be increased on foot of an appeal by prosecutors.

Joseph Hillen (aged 25), with an address at Glendasha Road, Forkhill, Co Armagh, had admitted killing Martin Mulligan (aged 53) in a rural area near Dundalk, Co. Louth, in the early hours of September 28, 2015, but denied it was murder.

The trial heard that Hillen initially denied all knowledge of Mr Mulligan's death, but ahead of his trial he made a voluntary statement in which he admitted stabbing the taxi driver following an altercation on the side of the road.

He was found guilty of manslaughter by a Central Criminal Court jury and was sentenced to seven years imprisonment with the final year suspended by Ms Justice Eileen Creedon on January 28, 2019. Passing sentence, Ms Justice Creedon said the verdict suggested the jury accepted Hillen believed he was acting in self-defence.

The Director of Public Prosecutions is seeking a review of Hillen’s sentence on grounds it was “unduly lenient”.

Counsel for the DPP, Patrick Treacy SC, told the Court of Appeal today that some manslaughters were “close to being indistinguishable from murder”.

In those cases, he said sentences of life imprisonment have been imposed and the DPP was submitting that this was a “worst-case” scenario. Failing that submission, he said it was a “high culpability case”.

Mr Treacy said the sentence was unduly lenient due to the particular devastation caused to the Mulligan family, the build-up to the killing, the aftermath, the use of the knife, the “brutality”, Hillen’s convictions for dangerous driving while on bail for the killing, his previous convictions and his “lack of honesty”.

Martin Mulligan at his daughter, Shauna's graduation with his other daughter, Sharon, and wife Grainne.
Martin Mulligan at his daughter, Shauna's graduation with his other daughter, Sharon, and wife Grainne.

He said the trial judge erred in categorising the killing as being in the upper mid-range for seriousness.

Mr Treacy said the trial judge gave “excessive credit” to Hillen for making a pre-trial voluntary statement. It would be “naive to lose sight of the tactical advantage” that gives the accused, Mr Treacy said. It allowed Hillen to put forward his version of events, without having to be cross-examined and where the deceased was not in a position to contradict anything.

When the trial judge gave Hillen credit for his pre-trial statement, she didn’t balance it against the way he conducted himself in garda interviews, where he was “utterly unhelpful”, counsel said.

According to Hillen’s “narrative”, Mr Treacy said the accused claimed the deceased had a knife, which he grabbed and “jabbed out” twice.

He said the “brutality” involved stabbing the knife 22.5cm into the deceased’s abdomen, right through the intestinal area. It was taken out and put “completely through” the deceased’s right thigh.

It was “savage penetration” into both the deceased’s abdomen and right thigh, each of which would cause catastrophic bleeding.

A “disturbing feature” was the 19cm cut down the deceased’s v-neck jumper. It was a “very unusual” feature which was never explained, Mr Treacy said. Hillen’s DNA was on the jumper, which indicated that the jumper was pulled and that the knife was used to slice, he added.

On the accused’s own account, Mr Treacy said Hillen’s companion drove the deceased’s car away and threw his keys into a field. That removed any means of escape for the unfortunate deceased who then had to deal with “these two young men on his own”.

Furthermore, Mr Treacy pointed to the “build-up and the aftermath” of the incident. He said Hillen had collected his companion in Dundalk earlier that day before driving through a stop sign, through traffic lights and onto the wrong side of the road. He said the car was pursued by gardaí, but the pursuit had to be abandoned because it was deemed too “dangerous”.

In the aftermath, he said Hillen and his companion left the scene with the weapon, leaving Mr Mulligan “on a country road to die”. No ambulance was called, nor were the gardaí. The only action Hillen took was to dispose of the knife three days later.

Mr Treacy said Hillen had simply pleaded not guilty and left it open to the jury to return a not guilty verdict, but DNA evidence placed him at the scene.

He said it was put forward on Hillen’s behalf that he was remorseful, but all of the above undermined his remorse.

Extraordinarily, he said the sentencing judge made no reference to aggravating factors in her judgment. It was a “fundamental error” in light of her repeated references to mitigating factors.

He said Hillen had 15 previous convictions including two incidents of dangerous driving while he was on bail for the killing, which was “troublesome”.

Counsel for Hillen, Brendan Grehan SC, said it was “baseless” for the DPP to contend that this manslaughter ought to fall within the most extreme category or at the higher level.

Mr Grehan said the trial judge had to respect the verdict of the jury, in circumstances where Hillen had claimed “excessive self-defence”. He said the DPP was “dissatisfied” with the fact the jury accepted Hillen’s narrative and had come to the Court of Appeal to complain about the sentence.

“I make no apology for saying this case falls squarely in the middle range,” Mr Grehan submitted, adding that most sentences for manslaughter fall within the four to 10-year bracket. It was an excessive self-defence case and there was nothing to justify going above the 10-year category.

He said the wounds were “quite unusual” and the pathologist accepted they could have been caused by backhanded thrusts from a kneeling position.

Mr Grehan said the decision to enter a guilty plea to manslaughter can be a “delicate issue” in cases of self-defence. A guilty plea to manslaughter could cause a jury to think the prosecution was “halfway” to murder.

The fact Hillen offered to plead guilty to manslaughter, but in fact did not enter the plea, might reduce the offer “somewhat, but not much”.

He said his client was only 21 years old at the time of the killing and had no previous convictions for crimes of violence.

Mr Grehan submitted that the headline sentence of 10 years was “absolutely correct” as was the categorisation of the offence as being mid-range. He said the judge was “merciful” towards Hillen and may have been lenient, but not so lenient for the sentence to be deemed “unduly lenient”.

He said his client had written a letter during the trial indicating some insight into the crime and remorse for Mr Mulligan’s family.

President of the Court of Appeal Mr Justice George Birmingham, who sat with Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy and Ms Justice Aileen Donnelly, said the court would reserve its judgment.

More on this topic

Man due in court in connection with assault and robbery in CorkMan due in court in connection with assault and robbery in Cork

Meath man, 21, accused of assaulting and robbing transgender escort told gardai he was attacked first with stilettoMeath man, 21, accused of assaulting and robbing transgender escort told gardai he was attacked first with stiletto

Judge orders release of 'exploited' cannabis grow house worker who court hears will now seek asylumJudge orders release of 'exploited' cannabis grow house worker who court hears will now seek asylum

In significant ruling court says barring order must be shown to have been 'produced' to breach accusedIn significant ruling court says barring order must be shown to have been 'produced' to breach accused


More in this Section

Husband and wife missing from Portmarnock since TuesdayHusband and wife missing from Portmarnock since Tuesday

Rescue mission underway for five fishermen off coast of DonegalRescue mission underway for five fishermen off coast of Donegal

Man arrested as police investigate Belfast stabbingMan arrested as police investigate Belfast stabbing

Two arrested as rival protesters come face to face at #Rally4PeaceTwo arrested as rival protesters come face to face at #Rally4Peace


Lifestyle

Want to be cultured this Christmas? From TV to podcasts to books, Ed Power has the definite list of everything you missed this year - so you can curl up on the couch and catch upThe definite list of everything you missed this year

Artist Ciara Rodgers teaches older people how to rediscover their creativity and regain confidence, says Rowena WalshBrush with art: Discovering your creative side in later life

Furniture, paintings, jewellery and silver are on offer at James Adam in Dublin, writes Des O’SullivanAll set for home run: See what's on offer at the James Adam sale in Dublin

It’s not too late to hunt out a unique gift. Des O’Sullivan previews sales in the lead-up to the festive seasonA flurry of auctions in Munster sets the scene for Christmas

More From The Irish Examiner