Axe de Havilland Feud damages suit because show is dramatisation, FX tells judge

Axe de Havilland Feud damages suit because show is dramatisation, FX tells judge

Dame Olivia de Havilland’s claim that the show Feud: Bette And Joan falsely portrayed her in a damaging light should be dismissed because it is a dramatised portrayal and not a documentary, a court has heard.

The 101-year-old double Oscar-winner sued FX Network over the docudrama, claiming it defamed her by incorrectly portraying her as a gossip and breached her right to privacy.

Dame Olivia claims her portrayal by Catherine Zeta-Jones was inaccurate for showing her calling her sister Joan Fontaine a “bitch” and commenting on Frank Sinatra’s drinking habits.

The network, in court in Los Angeles on Tuesday, appealed an earlier decision not to throw out the case, saying the genre can use creative licence to update her words for a “contemporary audience”.

Kelly Klaus, representing FX, said the British-America movie veteran may not have called her sibling a bitch, but did call her a “dragon lady” in an interview on her 100th birthday.

“Docudramas are understood not to be a literal retelling of history, that’s the role of documentaries,” he said.

Dame Olivia de Havilland says the show incorrectly portrayed her as a gossip (PA)
Dame Olivia de Havilland says the show incorrectly portrayed her as a gossip (PA)

Rejecting this would create an “incredibly dangerous” standard, Mr Klaus added.

Dame Olivia’s lawyer, Suzelle Smith, argued that dragon lady and bitch are not synonymous or equivalent in offensiveness.

“In my household, if you use the word bitch, you get your mouth washed out,” she said.

Ms Smith argued the show wrongly portrayed the Paris-based star as a hypocrite and a gossip who used vulgar terms.

“Olivia de Havilland has built a reputation of 100 years as a celebrity and she should get compensation for that,” she added.

Ms Smith also thanked the judges for seeing to the matter so quickly because of the Gone With The Wind actress’s age.

The star’s team also claims she was not consulted over the show, which focuses on the rivalry between Joan Crawford and Bette Davis, nor was she asked for permission for her to be depicted.

Lawyers for FX said the earlier ruling that the case should proceed is damaging for freedom of speech and could hamper creativity.

Dame Olivia, pictured here in 1959, won Oscars in 1946 and 1949 (PA)
Dame Olivia, pictured here in 1959, won Oscars in 1946 and 1949 (PA)

“Such a change inevitably would stifle the creativity of future Hemingways, Spielbergs, and Twains, with the nation’s literary discourse all the poorer for it,” they wrote in the lawsuit.

This is not the first time a major Hollywood company has been taken on by Dame Olivia, who won Oscars for 1946’s To Each His Own and 1949’s The Heiress.

She won a landmark victory over Warner Bros in 1943 which effectively ended actors’ contract servitude.

Joan Fontaine died in 2013 (PA)
Joan Fontaine died in 2013 (PA)

Dame Olivia is demanding damages from the network and for a permanent injunction preventing the show’s broadcast.

The Californian appeal court was sitting was at University of Southern California’s law school so the room-full of students could learn from the procedure.

Judges have 90 days to decide whether to overturn the previously ruling and dismiss the case.

More in this Section

New David Attenborough documentary Seven Worlds, One Planet captures life in AntarcticaNew David Attenborough documentary Seven Worlds, One Planet captures life in Antarctica

Ralf Little looks set to replace Ardal O’Hanlon on Death In ParadiseRalf Little looks set to replace Ardal O’Hanlon on Death In Paradise

People love me for who I am:  Irish activist named winner of The CirclePeople love me for who I am: Irish activist named winner of The Circle

Bruce Springsteen on creating some of his best work as he turns 70Bruce Springsteen on creating some of his best work as he turns 70


Lifestyle

Sunday Lunch costs €45 per person and includes several set courses but with a choice of mains.Restaurant Review: Bastible Restaurant, Dublin

It never ceases to stop me in my tracks when I hear my husband intone to our children one of the oft overused phrases from my stockpile of, “Can you just not?” categories.Lindsay Woods: If my children feel I’m doing it wrong then I must be doing it right

The season of mists and mellow fruitfulness — John Keats had it right about autumn.Eyes on the pies: Eight apple tarts put to the taste test

Simone Rocha invited ieStyle into her London studio for an exclusive look behind the scenes as she put the finishing touches to her acclaimed collection for Fashion Week. Rachel Marie Walsh reportsBeing Simone Rocha: An exclusive look behind the scenes

More From The Irish Examiner