Watchdog highlights €302m health overspend

Watchdog highlights €302m health overspend
Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe

By Eamon Quinn

The fiscal watchdog has endorsed the Government’s new growth projections, but in a significant move a week before Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe releases his 2019 budget, has warned about a €302m overspend in health.

Seamus Coffey, chair of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, or IFAC, said that health was showing “a consistent pattern of overruns where plans are not being met”.

In recent years the increase in corporation tax receipts “had masked” additional health spending which raises concerns about fuelling “an already fast-growing economy”, he told the Irish Examiner.

Last year the Government was forced to pump an additional €195m into health than it had originally planned. 

But IFAC separately endorsed new economic growth forecasts on which Minister Donohoe will base his budget spending and tax plans.

In the new projections, the Department of Finance raised its GDP growth forecast for this year to 7.4%, up from around 5% growth in its previous forecast in April. 

In 2019, it sees GDP expanding by 4.2%. Last week, the Economic and Social Research Institute projected 2018 GDP would grow even faster, by 9%.

The latest exchequer figures showed revenues from corporation tax continued to run ahead of target last month; Vat receipts made up lost ground; and income tax met its target. 

Excise duties again underperformed, however.

But the spotlight fell on the overspend in health. At €41.6bn for the first nine months, overall gross voted current spending was running slightly above target. 

But health spending of €11.45bn was 2.7% or €302m above target at this stage. 

The Department of Finance said that recruitment and the delivery of services were driving the health spending overruns.

Conall Mac Coille, chief economist at Davy, said the September exchequer figures don’t “change the budget arithmetic very much”. 

“It’s a case of corporation [tax revenue] making up for small shortfalls elsewhere,” he said.

At €793m, corporation tax receipts for the month brought in almost 4% more than was anticipated, which means the Government over the full nine months collected almost €5.16bn from this single tax source, already 6.3% or €306m above its budget target.

For all of 2017, corporation tax brought in €8.2bn and last month’s strong performance suggests the bounty this year could exceed €8.7bn. 

The buoyant corporate receipts have depended on a handful of the largest multinationals based here and watchdogs have long warned the Government against basing any future overall spending plans on a potentially unreliable tax revenue source. 

At almost €2.19bn, Vat receipts were above target by €42m last month, a Vat-paying month, which left Vat revenues over the full nine months almost on target, at over €11.57bn.

Excise duties were again disrupted by the switch to plain packaging for tobacco products. 

At almost €3.88bn, excise duties have now brought in €339m less than was anticipated over the first nine months.

“The baseline scenario, as set out by my department, is for continued strong economic growth this year and next. But we cannot take this for granted, especially in such an uncertain global environment,” Minister Donohoe said.

More on this topic

HSE's senior management team to be cut back HSE's senior management team to be cut back

Reform needed: Two-tier health serviceReform needed: Two-tier health service

Letter to the Editor: HSE doomed to failure as services are outsourcedLetter to the Editor: HSE doomed to failure as services are outsourced

Future of addiction charity under threat amid HSE reviewFuture of addiction charity under threat amid HSE review

More in this Section

Wetherspoons boss Tim Martin hits out at corporate governance rulesWetherspoons boss Tim Martin hits out at corporate governance rules

DCC shares fall 6% on profit declineDCC shares fall 6% on profit decline

Regulator: Banks still failing customersRegulator: Banks still failing customers

Sterling inches lower as Tory vote boost fadesSterling inches lower as Tory vote boost fades


Aileen Lee meets Christina Kenny - co-founder and design director of Lamb Design - to talk about her work and inspirations.Christina Kenny of Lamb Design: ‘I love bringing the outside in and inside out’

Tyrone designer Sharon Wauchob on her career and the worth of luxury fastion. By Paul McLachen.From Marc Jacobs to her own label, Tyrone designer Sharon Wauchob on her life in fashion

The recent sentencing of two teenage boys for the murder of Ana Kriégel has once again brought the issue of pornography into public discourse. The details of the case, which are finally coming into public knowledge, illuminate some very worrying trends that are pervasive in the modern adolescent world and as parents and indeed as a society we can no longer languish in complacency.Learning Points: Hardcore porn can pollute our children’s minds

HUSBAND and wife Justin and Jenny Green run Ballyvolane House, in Castlelyons, Co Cork. The mansion and former dairy farm, which was built in 1728, is where Justin grew up. Raised to Scottish parents in Hong Kong, Jenny met fellow hotelier Justin while working in the Mandarin Oriental Hotel. Having worked in the UK and Bali, they returned to manage Ballyvolane House, as an Irish country house, in 2004.Parents for the Planet: Green family has greener outlook at country house

More From The Irish Examiner