Swiss vote on 'rip-off initiative'

Swiss vote on 'rip-off initiative'

Foreign executives who moved their company headquarters to Switzerland to get better tax deals for their firms may find themselves paying the price for it this weekend.

A plan to crack down on excessive corporate pay packages is predicted to pass at the ballot box on Sunday.

If the “Rip-off Initiative” succeeds, shareholders will be given the right to hold a binding vote on a company’s compensation of executives and directors. This includes both base salary and bonuses.

It would also ban “golden hellos” and “golden goodbyes” – one-time bonuses that senior managers often receive when joining or leaving a company which can run into millions of pounds.

Finally, the proposal pushes greater corporate transparency, for example by requiring that all loans to executives be declared to shareholders.

Breaching the rules could lead to a fine of up to six annual salaries and up to three years in prison.

The measure targets all Swiss-based companies – homegrown and offshore alike - as long as their shares are publicly traded.

Some other European countries such as the Netherlands and Denmark already have similar legislation allowing shareholders at least a binding vote on executive compensation. In Britain, however, such “say-on-pay” votes are non-binding.

The proposal has divided Swiss business groups, political parties and unions. But public opinion in Switzerland – traditionally a haven for light-touch regulation and pro-business sentiment – has been overwhelmingly in favour of the Rip-off Initiative.

A survey conducted mid-February by the respected polling group gfs.bern found 64% of voters in favour of the proposal, 27% against, 9% undecided, with anger at perceived corporate greed the driving force for voters backing the initiative.

Public opinion toward executive pay is still shaped by the outrage at bank bosses who received million-pound bonuses during the 2008 financial crisis, when ordinary investors were seeing their dividends slashed and the value of their shares fall sharply.

The campaign for a “Yes” vote recently got an unexpected boost when it emerged that the outgoing board chairman of Swiss drug maker Novartis AG, Daniel Vasella, was due to receive 72 million Swiss francs (€59m) over five years as part of a deal to prevent him from going to a rival firm.

When Vasella – facing public outrage – dropped the deal, attention shifted to Edward Breen, the American chairman of Tyco, for reportedly earning 30 million francs (€24m) last year.

Opponents of the initiative warn that approving it would damage Switzerland’s competitiveness in the global economy and endanger jobs.

So far, no companies have publicly declared they would leave Switzerland if the referendum passes, said Brigitta Moser-Harder, a shareholder activist and backer of the proposal.

But Tyco is keeping its options open. “We await the outcome of the vote in Switzerland on Sunday and we will assess the impact at that time,” company spokesman Brett Ludwig said Friday.

The Swiss proposal comes on the heels of a European Union decision this week to cap bankers’ bonuses at one year’s base salary except in the case of overwhelming shareholder approval.

The idea that shareholders should have a strong say in their company’s affairs chimes with Switzerland’s tradition of direct democracy. Voters in the country who collect 100,000 signatures can force a binding referendum on any issue.

More in this Section

Huawei in US short reprieveHuawei in US short reprieve

No-deal Brexit tariffs could ‘massively reduce’ competitiveness, warn British farmersNo-deal Brexit tariffs could ‘massively reduce’ competitiveness, warn British farmers

UK brewer agrees £2.7bn sale to Hong Kong’s CKAUK brewer agrees £2.7bn sale to Hong Kong’s CKA

Abbey boss sees pay rise 15% despite profit collapseAbbey boss sees pay rise 15% despite profit collapse


Columnist and trained counsellor Fiona Caine offers guidance on how to cope when your husband is pushing boundaries.Ask a counsellor: ‘My husband is playing games with another woman – what should I do?’

We take a trip down memory lane and check out what happened on this day in years gone by by looking back at some Irish Examiner front pages and highlighting other events which went down in history across the world.August 20, 2019: A look back at what happened on this day in years gone by

More From The Irish Examiner