Savoy cinema fails in injunction to prevent development of entertainment venue at former Screen site

Savoy cinema fails in injunction to prevent development of entertainment venue at former Screen site
A statue outside the former Screen site.

An application for an injunction by the owners of Dublin's Savoy Cinema over a plan to turn the former Screen Cinema site into a 500-seat entertainment venue has been struck out by the High Court.

The Dublin Cinema Group (DGG), which owns the Savoy in O'Connell Street, sought the injunction because it fears the Balark Group, to which the Screen was sold to in 2016, is going to open a cinema or theatre there. If it did, DCG says, that would breach a restrictive covenant in the sale agreement which meant the Screen could not be used as a cinema or theatre until 2036.

The Screen site in Townsend Street is just down the road from the Savoy. DCG says another cinema will substantially impair its interest in the Savoy.

Balark got planning permission to redevelop the site and the adjoining College House to include a 500-seat "entertainment venue" in which experienced entertainment industry Paddy McKillen junior's Press Up Entertainment Group expressed his desire to operate the venue.

DCG, after failing to get undertakings in relation to the cinema/theatre covenant in relation to this planning permission, sued Balark Investments and Balark Trading GP. It sought an injunction in relation to the implementing of the planning approval and declarations in relation to the restrictive covenant.

Balark then brought an application seeking to strike out the proceedings as unsustainable, bound to fail and conferred no practical benefit on DCG. The application was opposed by DCG.

During the hearing of that application, Balark gave an undertaking that a restrictive covenant in the sale agreement with DCG prevents its use as a cinema/theatre and also applies to any successor in title.

The issue of the injunction remained and, today, Mr Justice Michael Twomey ruled the application was bound to fail and said it must be struck out.

He said the court cannot see any legal basis for granting an injunction prohibiting construction "as distinct from using" the property as an entertainment venue.

The judge said it was possible DCG might be right not to trust Balark and it was possible Balark might be hoping or intending to use it as a cinema/theatre in the future if it transpires it is not in fact possible to use it as an entertainment venue without breaching the covenant and undertakings to the court.

It was also possible Balark might be intending this use in breach of those matters.

"However, that is a hypothetical situation which does not concern this court," he said.

"It is not the purpose of the courts to police the intention or possible intentions, as distinct from the acts, of commercial parties."

It is also not the court's purpose to entertain or engage with possible future hypothetical situations, he said.

More on this topic

Man charged with careless driving causing teenager's death in BallincolligMan charged with careless driving causing teenager's death in Ballincollig

€7,500 damages for ex-prisoner who had to 'slop out' in prison€7,500 damages for ex-prisoner who had to 'slop out' in prison

Trial of man accused of murdering Detective Garda Adrian Donohoe put back for 'logistic reasons'Trial of man accused of murdering Detective Garda Adrian Donohoe put back for 'logistic reasons'

Girl, 10, awarded €56k in damages after radiator fell on her foot in schoolGirl, 10, awarded €56k in damages after radiator fell on her foot in school

More in this Section

eir teams up with Amazon Prime to offer customers access to the service as part of TV packageeir teams up with Amazon Prime to offer customers access to the service as part of TV package

Business movers: Award-winning Katie Cunningham joins BBDO DublinBusiness movers: Award-winning Katie Cunningham joins BBDO Dublin

Non-stop flight from Heathrow to Sydney takes offNon-stop flight from Heathrow to Sydney takes off

Connectivity’s vital role in future working life of rural communitiesConnectivity’s vital role in future working life of rural communities


Lifestyle

Jackie Turner, genetic counsellor, Clinical Genetics Centre for Ophthalmology, Mater Hospital, DublinWorking Life: 'I catch the quiet 6:15 train, a place to gather my thoughts and plan my day'

The repeat bouts of sinus infection you describe indicate you need to get in front of this annual issue by supporting your immune system.Natural Health: 'Every winter I get a nasty sinus infection'

The TV chef chats to Lauren Taylor about feeding his family and his kids’ ever-changing tastes.Jamie Oliver: ‘About 3/10 of our family meals are idyllic – that’s normal’

Yearning to turn your rooms into soothing havens? Gabrielle Fagan asks The White Company founder Chrissie Rucker for her secrets.How to create a calm, tranquil home – according to The White Company’s Chrissie Rucker

More From The Irish Examiner