Ryanair fails in British High Court bid to block strikes by UK pilots

Ryanair fails in British High Court bid to block strikes by UK pilots

Ryanair has lost a High Court bid in England to block strike action by its UK pilots – hours after winning a similar legal move in Dublin.

A judge sitting in London today rejected an urgent application by the airline for an injunction against the British Airline Pilots’ Association (Balpa).

The decision by Mrs Justice Lambert came after Ryanair succeeded at the High Court in Dublin earlier today in its bid to prevent pilots based in Ireland from going on a 48-hour strike from midnight on Thursday.

The airline sought an urgent injunction from the judge in London just hours before the start of threatened industrial action by members of Balpa in a dispute over pay and conditions.

After hearing submissions from Ryanair and Balpa, the judge dismissed the various grounds raised by the airline.

Strike action by UK Ryanair pilots is due to take place on Thursday and Friday this week, with a second round of dates in September.

Paul Gott QC, for Ryanair, told Mrs Justice Lambert during the hearing that strike action could be “enormously disruptive”, and Ryanair would suffer “significant reputational” damage.

Mr Gott submitted that Balpa had not conducted a ballot which complied with the requirements of labour relations legislation.

But Andrew Burns QC, representing Balpa, accused Ryanair of raising “trivial and immaterial technicalities”, and argued that it was “readily apparent” that the union had “substantially complied” with legislative obligations.

After Mrs Justice Lambert’s ruling, Balpa said she had rejected Ryanair’s “various technical and legal arguments”, and agreed that the union’s industrial action ballot and procedures were lawful, “and so the strike can proceed”.

Balpa said it has responded to the legal victory “by offering an olive branch to Ryanair – a framework to allow constructive negotiations to take place and if agreed by Ryanair will avoid the need for strikes”.

Brian Strutton, the union’s general secretary, said: “Ryanair was foolish to bring this into the High Court rather than the negotiating room.

“We offered to meet Ryanair management at Acas to negotiate a resolution, but instead they attempted a legal bludgeon. That’s backfired."

“However, we are clear that we want to settle the dispute and bring about a change in Ryanair for the better.

“Pilots in Ryanair are seeking the same kind of policies and agreements that exist in other airlines – our demands are not unreasonable. We want to address issues like pensions; loss of licence insurance; maternity benefits; allowances; and harmonise pay across the UK in a fair, transparent, and consistent structure.

“We hope that Ryanair will take up our offer of a way forward this evening so we can call off this action. We urge Ryanair to change their attitude to dealing with us, and adopt a constructive approach.

“In the event that Ryanair rejects our overture and therefore the action over the next two days does go ahead, we apologise to the passengers who will be affected. Such action could have been avoided if Ryanair adopts a different approach.”

More on this topic

Ryanair delays caused by IT glitch, airline saysRyanair delays caused by IT glitch, airline says

Ryanair receives timely boost by agreeing German pilot pay dealRyanair receives timely boost by agreeing German pilot pay deal

Fresh strikes planned by Ryanair pilots in UKFresh strikes planned by Ryanair pilots in UK

Veteran Eddie Wilson is new boss at RyanairVeteran Eddie Wilson is new boss at Ryanair

More in this Section

Plans lodged for 368 'boutique' student bed spaces in Dublin's LibertiesPlans lodged for 368 'boutique' student bed spaces in Dublin's Liberties

Painkiller OxyContin manufacturer files for bankruptcyPainkiller OxyContin manufacturer files for bankruptcy

CSO figures show huge increase in Ireland's exports in JulyCSO figures show huge increase in Ireland's exports in July

Trump approves release of oil reserves if needed after Saudi attackTrump approves release of oil reserves if needed after Saudi attack


Lifestyle

Make-up artist Terry Barber reveals the secret to pulling off the bold lip look.This is how to make black lipstick work in real life, according to a catwalk make-up pro

Off to the Japan? After a trip to Tokyo, Ella Walker outlines the best things to eat between matches.These are the dishes to try if you’re going to Tokyo for the Rugby World Cup

It still surprises me as I am achingly private and do not enjoy being at the centre of attention.This Much I Know: Actor Aislin McGuckin

Bride Geraldine O’Donovan felt as wonderful as she looked on her big day — knowing she was supporting a cause close to her heart as she donned her wedding gown.Wedding on the Week: Supporting a cause close to their hearts

More From The Irish Examiner