Options required for carbon tax to work

Options required for carbon tax to work
File image

In the past few weeks we have seen both the threat, and then the deferral, of two taxes. Though very different in appearance, were either primarily designed to raise money?

Local Property Tax was a creature of the bailout.

It was introduced to secure the payment of the household levy, which itself had been introduced to satisfy our international lenders that Ireland was serious about a property tax to bolster flagging national finances and to get more people into the tax net.

Even so, LPT has only ever raised about 1% of the total tax take and PRSI collected and has never been a major exchequer contributor.

Given that it was falling due for revision in 2019, and given the prospect of inevitable rises because it is based on property values, its review has been kicked down the road a further year.

It continues to serve a purpose in ensuring that a broader range of people contribute to the exchequer.

The carbon tax is different. We rely too heavily on fossil fuels and the purpose of a carbon tax is to change behaviours so that people rely on them less, rather than raise money for the exchequer.

In fact, the Taoiseach said as much at the start of the year. He noted that a carbon tax is an environmental tax designed to change behaviour and that money raised through carbon tax from households should be given back to households to compensate for the additional cost.

Sometimes tax changes do result in behavioural changes. The plastic bag levy has undoubtedly worked in reducing plastic litter in this country — if you don’t believe me, just visit a country where it hasn’t been applied.

But it also worked because there were viable alternatives and retailers co-operated. It was highly visible and everyone knows that the levy on a plastic bag is 22c.

But do we know how much we are already paying in carbon taxes on our fuel bills?

The existing carbon tax charges of €52.67 on a tonne of coal, €36.67 on a tonne of peat briquettes, and anything up to €61.75 on 1,000 litres of home heating oil don’t seem to have done too much to change our consumption patterns.

Perhaps we are not sufficiently aware of the full extent of the carbon tax charges that already exist, and even if we were, there is not much we can do to change our fossil fuel spending patterns.

It is not viable for many householders to change their heating systems, and it is not possible for commuters to change their travel arrangements without alternative reliable forms of public transport which use fossil fuels less intensively than private cars.

This is why the Joint Committee on Climate Change advocated increases to carbon taxes last month but said the increases shouldn’t take full effect until 2030.

The committee also said the tax should be hypothetical — in other words reserved for particular purposes like compensating poorer families rather than going into the general exchequer pool.

In this, they were echoing the Taoiseach in January and proposing a tax that doesn’t generate money.

LPT was introduced to demonstrate that action was being taken by the country.

Carbon tax was introduced to prompt action to be taken by the taxpayer. Taxes may have a role in behavioural change, but such change can only happen where there is an alternative.

We are wasting our time discussing the pros and cons of carbon taxation without viable alternatives for consumers and businesses alike.

Brian Keegan is director of public policy and taxation at Chartered Accountants Ireland

More on this topic

Irish Examiner View: Clean air campaign - Time to stop engine idlingIrish Examiner View: Clean air campaign - Time to stop engine idling

Carbon tax rise sees increase in cost of home heatingCarbon tax rise sees increase in cost of home heating

Department considered raising carbon tax by €10 in budgetDepartment considered raising carbon tax by €10 in budget

Car sales in Europe get late-year boost helped by incentivesCar sales in Europe get late-year boost helped by incentives


More in this Section

Gilead Sciences adds 140 jobs in Ireland with new Dublin baseGilead Sciences adds 140 jobs in Ireland with new Dublin base

Gilead to create 140 jobs in Dublin and CorkGilead to create 140 jobs in Dublin and Cork

JYSK announce first Dublin storeJYSK announce first Dublin store

Asos and Next drop Boohoo after Leicester factory allegationsAsos and Next drop Boohoo after Leicester factory allegations


Lifestyle

Dónal Clancy is a musician from An Rinn in Co Waterford. He will perform the music of his late father, Liam Clancy, in a special online solo performance on Thursday at 7pm as part of this year's Clonmel Junction Festival.Question of Taste: Dónal Clancy

BETWEEN 1973 and early 1975, John Lennon split with Yoko Ono, took up with his assistant May Pang and embarked on a period of intense creativity and outrageous behaviour. Lennon later described this time as his “lost weekend”.Rufus Wainwright has returned a new man

Stan O’Sullivan tells Ellie O’Byrne about the genre-busting album from 2007 that probably doesn’t get the recognition it deservesB-Side the Leeside - Cork’s Greatest Records: Louder & Clearer from Stanley Super 800

In recent times one of the most recurring and troubling conversations I have with teenagers, in therapy, is around their use of marijuana. Often parents seek out therapy because they have noticed a dramatic shift in their child’s behaviour.Richard Hogan: Beware of making light of your teen's marijuana use

More From The Irish Examiner