Lawyer urges court to throw out Uber's latest appeal over VAT bill

Lawyer urges court to throw out Uber's latest appeal over VAT bill

An epic court battle against Uber in the UK took another twist as the car-sharing giant came a step closer to being liable for a potential £1.5 billion in unpaid VAT.

The Good Law Project won a case against bosses at HM Revenues and Customs who must now reveal whether the agency has assessed Uber's VAT tax liabilities last month.

But Uber subsequently filed an appeal against the decision before HMRC would have been forced to make the disclosure.

On Monday, the Good Law Project, which is run by anti-Brexit campaigner Jolyon Maugham QC, filed documents with the Court of Appeal to have Uber's own appeal urgently thrown out.

Mr Maugham told the PA news agency: "The more time passes without an assessment being raised the more VAT is lost - forever.

"Whatever costs Uber run up pursuing a hopeless appeal will be dwarfed by the £4m or so lost every week if no assessment is raised.

"We hope and expect the Court of Appeal to give this ruse the short shrift it deserves."

The Good Law Project initially attempted to take Uber to court to force them to disclose their tax affairs, but attempts for a protective costs ruling failed, making the case unviable financially.

Instead, the group took HMRC to court demanding the taxman assess Uber for VAT liabilities. It calculates that Uber could be on the hook for £1.5 billion.

HMRC had previously claimed it had made no assessment, but once the court case was launched, it declined to confirm whether the position had changed or not.

Uber argues that because it is a platform that brings drivers and riders together, rather than a transport business, it is the driver who is liable for VAT on any rides rather than the company.

But because the threshold for VAT is only for individuals earning more than £85,000 a year, none of the drivers need to charge it.

HMRC claimed in court its dealings with Uber were commercially sensitive information which could undermine confidentiality, but this was dismissed by the court.

Mrs Justice Lieven said she did not accept HMRC's argument "that this approach would undermine taxpayer confidentiality because any third party could judicially review HMRC and then seek disclosure of the taxpayer's affairs.

"Plainly, if HMRC thought that a claim was being brought as a fishing expedition, or simply to obtain confidential information, then it could and doubtless would defend the claim on that basis without disclosing anything confidential."

Lawyer urges court to throw out Uber's latest appeal over VAT bill

She added that even if the case was simply about weighing up Uber's right to confidentiality, "I would find that the intrusion into Uber's confidentiality (or article 8 rights) is actually rather slight.

"The only information which at this stage HMRC want to disclose is whether or not they have made a protective assessment."

Despite Uber and HMRC's attempts to withhold any potential information through the courts, company documents show the firm recognises the VAT issue could heavily impact the business.

Uber Technologies' accounts in the US say: "Losing the (case in which drivers can be classified as workers) may lead the UK tax regulator (HMRC) to classify us as a transportation provider, requiring us to pay VAT (20%) on gross bookings both retroactively and prospectively."

The most recent UK accounts filed with Companies House also add: "The company is involved in a proceeding in the UK involving HMRC, the tax regulator in the UK, which is seeking to classify the company as a transportation provider."

Uber declined to comment.

Separately, Uber is battling with the courts after Transport for London stripped it of its licence. The decision is under appeal.

More on this topic

Uber launches appeal against London licence refusalUber launches appeal against London licence refusal

Uber loses licence to operate in LondonUber loses licence to operate in London

Some Irish customers charged for Uber trips they didn't takeSome Irish customers charged for Uber trips they didn't take

Uber to start online grocery deliveries following latest acquisitionUber to start online grocery deliveries following latest acquisition

More in this Section

China welcomes preliminary deal in trade war it blames on USChina welcomes preliminary deal in trade war it blames on US

Irish shares climb as election drives sterlingIrish shares climb as election drives sterling

Profits fall at hotel groupProfits fall at hotel group

Profits rise 35% as gym group Flyefit expandsProfits rise 35% as gym group Flyefit expands


Lifestyle

Want to be cultured this Christmas? From TV to podcasts to books, Ed Power has the definite list of everything you missed this year - so you can curl up on the couch and catch upThe definite list of everything you missed this year

Artist Ciara Rodgers teaches older people how to rediscover their creativity and regain confidence, says Rowena WalshBrush with art: Discovering your creative side in later life

Furniture, paintings, jewellery and silver are on offer at James Adam in Dublin, writes Des O’SullivanAll set for home run: See what's on offer at the James Adam sale in Dublin

It’s not too late to hunt out a unique gift. Des O’Sullivan previews sales in the lead-up to the festive seasonA flurry of auctions in Munster sets the scene for Christmas

More From The Irish Examiner