Fisheries minister criticises 'misinformed' lobbyists on EU quotas

Fisheries minister criticises 'misinformed' lobbyists on EU quotas

An international lobby group for sustainable fishing has accused ministers across Europe of ensuring overfishing will continue as a result of the 2019 Annual Fisheries Negotiations which concluded early today.

The agreements reached in the small hours were welcomed by industry locally as Agriculture and Food Minister Michael Creed dismissed non-industry criticisms as ‘misinformed’.

Rebecca Hubbard, programme director of Our Fish said the setting of fishing quotas should have followed scientific advice.

“Instead, we saw another absurd all-night meeting behind closed doors where ministers haggled over fishing quotas like kids trading football cards,” Ms Hubbard said.

The organisation Our Fish works to end overfishing and wasteful discarding and challenges EU governments to deliver transparent, sustainable management of Europe’s fisheries.


She added: “By choosing to set fishing limits above scientific advice for many stocks, they have ignored European citizens and all of the evidence that shows ending overfishing will deliver healthy fish stocks, more jobs and security for coastal communities.”

Killybegs Fishermen’s Organisation CEO, Seán O’Donoghue said the negotiations had generally positive outcomes and noted there was a workable solution adopted, to the landings obligation, thus avoiding the potential for early closures of a large number of fisheries.

The landings obligation, or discard ban, comes into play next year and will outlaw the practice of discarding juvenile fish at sea. It had led to fears that vessels with capacity for further fishing would be hampered due to meeting their full allowance of “choke species”.

A choke species is a term used to describe a species with a low quota that can cause a vessel to stop fishing even if they still have a quota for other species.

“The implementation of the landings obligation, as laid out in the Commission’s proposals, would have had large negative consequences for Ireland’s whitefish and pelagic sectors as the choke species' factor could have triggered the closure of most fisheries in the early months of 2019,” he said.

The prospect of 'choke species' paralysing the Irish fishing industry was a very credible threat with knock-on effects for a vast array of sustainable fisheries, hitherto able to function normally, being caught in the slip-stream.

“I am glad to say the Council has adopted a workable solution to the 'choke' situation with the allocation of bycatch quotas to the Member States for the five stocks where a zero TAC [ total allowable catch] was set,” he said.

Meanwhile, Mr Creed described some of the commentaries on EU negotiations on fish quotas as ‘misinformed.’

He told RTÉ’s Morning Ireland some commentators would appear to prefer to see “rusting fishing trawlers tied up in ports,” and emphasised none of the concessions agreed was outside scientific advice.


Breakdown of yearly fisheries quota deal

By Joe Leogue

Agriculture and Marine Minister Michael Creed has described the deal struck at the 2019 Annual Fisheries Negotiations as a balanced outcome to what was a “challenging and complex negotiation”.

The final deal negotiated provides for maintenance of quotas year on year, with an increase in value to €260m.

A ban on the practice of discarding juvenile fish at sea will come into place next year.

Fisheries minister criticises 'misinformed' lobbyists on EU quotas

“My primary ambition at these negotiations was to set quotas for Irish fishermen that will support the livelihoods of fishermen and at the same time respect the scientific advice for stocks,” Mr Creed said.

The particular challenge facing the fishing industry from the beginning of 2019 is landing all catches and ending discarding of fish at sea.

"Our fishing industry has been fully supportive of the new policy while seeking to find solutions that will allow fishermen to continue viable and sustainable fisheries,” he said.

The ban had caused concerns that it would cause difficulties for vessels that had hauled in its quota of species with a low allowance, or so-called choke species.

However, Killybegs Fishermen’s Organisation CEO Sean O’Donoghue said the allocation of bycatch quotas to the Member States for the five stocks where a zero total allowable catch was set was a “workable solution”.

    The deal makes the following adjustments to Ireland’s quota:

  • An overall increase of 30 % for whitefish
  • A 20% cut for mackerel
  • A 35 % increase for Atlanto-Scandian herring
  • An 18 % increase in western horse mackerel
  • Also as part of the agreement:

  • There will be a 92% increase in Rockall haddock and 25% increase in monkfish quotas off Ireland’s north-west.
  • Increases of 20% in haddock, 16% for cod, 28% for hake and 47% for megrims in the Celtic Sea.

“We knew coming into these negotiations that, in line with the scientific advice, some substantial cuts would be necessary to protect some of our key fisheries such as herring, mackerel and prawns,” Mr Creed said.

“To their credit, the Irish fishing industry accepted that these cuts were necessary. In the interests of sustainability, we accepted a cut to our prawn quota of 32%, which reflects the scientific advice.”

More in this Section

China welcomes preliminary deal in trade war it blames on USChina welcomes preliminary deal in trade war it blames on US

Irish shares climb as election drives sterlingIrish shares climb as election drives sterling

Profits fall at hotel groupProfits fall at hotel group

Profits rise 35% as gym group Flyefit expandsProfits rise 35% as gym group Flyefit expands


Want to be cultured this Christmas? From TV to podcasts to books, Ed Power has the definite list of everything you missed this year - so you can curl up on the couch and catch upThe definite list of everything you missed this year

Artist Ciara Rodgers teaches older people how to rediscover their creativity and regain confidence, says Rowena WalshBrush with art: Discovering your creative side in later life

Furniture, paintings, jewellery and silver are on offer at James Adam in Dublin, writes Des O’SullivanAll set for home run: See what's on offer at the James Adam sale in Dublin

It’s not too late to hunt out a unique gift. Des O’Sullivan previews sales in the lead-up to the festive seasonA flurry of auctions in Munster sets the scene for Christmas

More From The Irish Examiner