Britain’s hostility to business is astonishing

Britain’s hostility to business is astonishing

One of the many remarkable outcomes of the Brexit debacle is the disdain displayed towards the business community by the UK political establishment, writes Joe Gill.

It seems as if every warning from significant employers and their representatives is treated with contempt in the populist rush to leave the European Union.

This animosity is odd in a society built, over the past 100 years, primarily on investment from the private sector.

Britain’s industry forged companies that could innovate, compete, and expand across international markets. They committed significant sums of capital and engaged in large-scale job creation to support their strategies.

Over time, however, the ownership of the private sector in the UK has changed dramatically.

Whereas UK shareholders owned the vast bulk of private companies a century ago, today, enterprise on the ground in Britain is dominated by companies owned outside of it.

It now seems as if the voices representing that enterprise are unwelcome more because of who they are than what they are communicating.

It looks like a case of shooting the messenger rather than hearing the message.

Hence, a German chief executive of Europe’s largest aerospace company, Airbus, issuing reasonable warnings about his level of investment in the UK, is met with Second World War quips. Japanese comments about car-making are responded to with references to whaling.

God love any Irish man or woman having the temerity to comment on British industry.

This risible behaviour is occurring at a time when long-term strategic investment in the UK is being weighed up.

If you are deciding on investments worth hundreds of millions of pounds, which rely on long-term confidence in UK support for business, how should you consider the current situation?

The commitment to be at the heart of the EU marketplace has been shredded.

A hard-negotiated agreement between the sovereign UK government and 27 others has been unilaterally binned by the British.

Against this backdrop, why should corporations like Airbus and Nissan not be reconsidering their long-term investments in the UK?

What the headline-grabbing Brexiteers are responding to are only those few business chiefs who have had the stomach to put their heads above the parapet. There are many more who think the same, but say little in public.

Moreover, a huge number of companies are growing and developing around the world that are determined to establish a presence in Europe.

Can you imagine how these are thinking about the circus in London?

All of this will be compared and contrasted with how the Irish establishment engages with business.

Too many times over the decades, Ireland has aped what goes on in the UK.

We are doing that with health, currently, and labour unions, too, have often adopted the practices that were more at home in early 20th century Britain than in 2019.

Hopefully, a more constructive engagement is now underway.

That contract should exchange the creation of well-paid, long-term employment for an environment that welcomes investment and which provides a stable set of rules and regulations that are not subject to extreme political volatility.

The latter is what now defines politics in the UK and elements of it have broken out, too, in continental Europe and the US.

Those voices are too often attached to a narrative that contains large dollops of racism, nativism, and jingoism.

Is it possible, amid all this, that Ireland could provide a beacon of rationality that rejects a worldview anchored in a misty-eyed nostalgia for the 19th century, when gunboats and white people felt entitled to control everything?

- Joe Gill is director of origination and corporate broking with Goodbody Stockbrokers. His views are personal.

More on this topic

Migrants are always at risk of crossing a lineMigrants are always at risk of crossing a line

Boris Johnson putting feet on Macron’s table ’embarrassing’ – Alastair CampbellBoris Johnson putting feet on Macron’s table ’embarrassing’ – Alastair Campbell

Blind Brexit ideologues will hammer the BritishBlind Brexit ideologues will hammer the British

Boris Johnson puts foot on table during Brexit talks with Emmanuel MacronBoris Johnson puts foot on table during Brexit talks with Emmanuel Macron

More in this Section

UK Ryanair flights take off as normal despite pilots’ strikeUK Ryanair flights take off as normal despite pilots’ strike

Here are the 9 steps for businesses to take to prepare for BrexitHere are the 9 steps for businesses to take to prepare for Brexit

Tesco ‘could ban brands’ with excessive plastic from shelvesTesco ‘could ban brands’ with excessive plastic from shelves

Around 50 SMEs see sales rise by more than €1m in four months in eBay pilot programmeAround 50 SMEs see sales rise by more than €1m in four months in eBay pilot programme

More by this author

Ducking and diving to survive stormy timesDucking and diving to survive stormy times

How investors can shelter from the sterling crisisHow investors can shelter from the sterling crisis

Ryanair and Glanbia have much to prove to marketsRyanair and Glanbia have much to prove to markets

All Irish firms selling into Britain hit by sterlingAll Irish firms selling into Britain hit by sterling


Lifestyle

Kylie Jenner’s best friend has teamed up with a global retailer on her first collection.Who is Anastasia Karanikolaou? The Instagram megastar who has just launched a fashion range

The trials and tribulations of bringing babies along for the ride.5 baby-friendly destinations for your first family holiday

Audrey's been sorting out Cork people for ages.Ask Audrey: 'There's a shortage of handsome, clean men, so I’m seeing a guy from Kanturk'

A beloved part of many an Irish childhood, the artist, author, and environmentalist Don Conroy tells Donal O’Keeffe why he loves his ‘abusive’ friend Dustin the Turkey, why big men hug him at festivals, and why he worries for Greta Thunberg.Art of the matter: Don Conroy on why he worries for Greta Thunberg

More From The Irish Examiner