Car insurance premiums likely to fall following court ruling over Setanta collapse

Car insurance premiums likely to fall following court ruling over Setanta collapse

Car insurance premiums are likely to fall “in the short to medium term” following a Supreme Court ruling over the Setanta Insurance collapse, writes Conall Ó Fátharta, Irish Examiner.

A junior minister said while the Department of Finance was not in a position to make a demand of any insurance company as to how they price their product, “it will be seen as a breach of faith” if companies were not willing to drop prices as a result of last week’s ruling.

A judgment has overturned previous court findings the Motor Insurers’ Bureau of Ireland (MIBI) should pick up the bill as a result of the demise of the insurance company. The MIBI is funded by the insurance industry.

Minister of state Eoghan Murphy yesterday told the Oireachtas committee on finance, public expenditure and reform that the recent decision of the courts “removes a major uncertainty” from the industry.

He expects the court’s decision “to be reflected in pricing” of premiums.

Mr Murphy said the Government was not in a position to react to calls it fully compensate those affected by the Setanta collapse.

As a result, claimants will now be compensated by the State’s Insurance Compensation Fund (ICF) for only 65% of the claim, up to a maximum of €825,000. Claimants will also be entitled to a further sum from the Setanta liquidation but current indications suggest there would not be sufficient funding available to cover the 35% gap.

Insurers had argued previous rulings were contributory factors in premiums rising as they had to make financial provisions, in the event of the MIBI providing cover for claims in the event of an insurance company collapsing in the future.

Minister Murphy said the implications of the ruling needed to be considered carefully before deciding on the best way forward.

However, he said the Government was prioritising payments to be made by the ICF and that this would happen “as soon as possible”.

“There are 1,639 outstanding third-party claims.

“The first tranche of payments that are going to be made, and these are rough figures at the moment because we are still working through this, is roughly 250 payments. They will be made up of Personal Injuries Assessment Board orders to pay roughly about 155, court orders roughly 61, other settled cases roughly 34. These will be verified by the State claims agency very shortly,” the minister said.

Sinn Féin’s Pearse Doherty said the minister had “given literally no clarity whatsoever” to the thousands of people waiting years for information on payments. He also claimed insurance companies had been using the Setanta collapse to “fleece” consumers.

Fianna Fáil’s Michael McGrath criticised the Government for refusing to step in to assure those affected by the Setanta collapse that 100% of the claims would be covered. He also read a letter received by someone awaiting a payment from their solicitor who had noted the consequences of the judgment “were not good” and that the situation was “a total mess”.

“People have been hung out to dry here, Minister, that is the reality. People could be held personally liable for any shortfall as a result of a claim,” he said.

Responding to a number of anecdotes from committee members about exorbitant price hikes from constituents, Mr Murphy said: “We all have anecdotes and anecdotes go in either direction.” The minister said he had become “a sort of focal point” for people complaining about premium hikes and had been approached in public situations, like weddings, by people wishing to vent their anger about the cost of motor insurance.

This story first appeared in the Irish Examiner.

More in this Section

One in four planing Christmas shopping trip outside state - AAOne in four planing Christmas shopping trip outside state - AA

Tech firm Horizon8 picks Cork as Europe HQTech firm Horizon8 picks Cork as Europe HQ

Abbey eyes more Irish work as profits fallAbbey eyes more Irish work as profits fall

Providence shares see bounce on Tony O’Reilly exitProvidence shares see bounce on Tony O’Reilly exit


Overshadowed by its giant neighbours it may be, but the smallest of the main Blasket islands, Beginish, is no less impressive in its own right.The Islands of Ireland: The miracle of Beginish

‘The days of our years are threescore years and ten — Psalm 90How to tell an animal’s age in a heartbeat

We often hear how nature will do well, even come back from the brink of extinction, if given a chance and some human help.Birds of prey on the rise

In our country we still have places that bear no evidence of disturbance by man, that are in their pristine state and rich with all the elements that feed the spirit and deliver us into the world beyond the skin of the time and circumstances we live in.Unique ambience of Dursey Island under threat

More From The Irish Examiner