Big Four face stricter fines

The world’s ‘big four’ accounting firms will face potential fines of £10m (€11.5m) or more, in the UK, for serious rule breaches from June, writes Huw Jones.

That figure is double the record penalty to date.

Britain’s Financial Reporting Council (FRC) said that it has accepted the findings of a study carried out in November by former judge Christopher Clarke, which recommended much bigger fines for serious misdeeds by the world’s biggest accountants.

Larger fines are part of the FRC’s push to bolster its credibility after being heavily criticised by lawmakers for being too slow to take on the big accountants caught up in company scandals.

Under the council’s disciplinary procedure, it sets out a case against an auditor or individual accountant at an independent tribunal before asking the tribunal to set a fine at a specific level.

The record amount agreed by a tribunal so far is £5.1m (€5.8m) for PwC over its audit of accountancy multinational RSM Tenon.

Mr Clarke has recommended an increase in fines to £10m (€11.5m) or more for seriously poor audit work from a ‘big four’ accounting firm — meaning PwC, KPMG, EY, and Deloitte — who check the books of most international blue-chip companies.

The FRC also accepted other recommendations from Mr Clarke to make greater use of non-financial penalties and to exclude dishonest auditors from the accounting profession for at least 10 years.

However, fines will be discounted in line with the level of co-operation during an investigation to encourage early settlement, the FRC said.

A £10m (€11.5m) fine is still small compared with penalties imposed by Britain’s Financial Conduct Authority for breaches of financial rules.

Britain’s Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales accounting industry body has already warned that exacting retribution through big fines could harm the marketplace.

It said such action could end up prompting some firms to quit auditing.


More in this Section

Better systems can aid business of giving money to tackle poverty

Pound recovers losses after UK's crunch Brexit vote

Ireland under fresh attack from EU on corporation tax

Datalex shares tank by nearly 60% as losses loom


New series explores Ireland's remote townlands and its people

James McAvoy is a Glass act in latest film

Turning 30: Regrets, advice and reflection from those who've hit the milestone

Mild winter inspires new season’s looks

More From The Irish Examiner