Top 8: The best decaf coffees to drink at any time that won't disrupt your sleep

In the hands of good roasters, there is hope
Top 8: The best decaf coffees to drink at any time that won't disrupt your sleep

Our Top 8 has plenty of roasters you can trust

Decaffeinated coffee can be disappointing. Without the caffeine kick that gives us a perceived or real energy lift, what can be left is a bland drink that becomes even more bland when we add milk. But in the hands of good roasters, there is hope, and today’s challenge was to find the best of them.

Introduced in 1906 by Ludwig Roselius in Bremen, Café Hag was the first decaf on the market. However, the decaffeination process, which involved using chemical solvents to extract the caffeine, received bad press. Since then, water has been used to extract caffeine through Swiss water extraction or sugar cane and water.

Barista and YouTuber James Hoffmann is a terrific source of information on decaf and contrasts each method. He doesn’t favour one over another but says choosing a roaster you can trust is more important. Our Top 8 has plenty of those.

Like regular coffee, decaf contains antioxidants which can add to our health armoury. Decaf means we can enjoy coffee at any time of day or night without fear of losing sleep.

We also tasted instant decaf, mostly sweet and lacking good coffee flavours. However, M&S decaf Rich Roast coffee bags (€4) were as good as the same brand’s ground decaf.

To make good coffee, let the water sit in kettle for a few seconds once boiled. Whole coffee beans and ground coffee freeze well.

Cloud Picker 250g €10.50

Cloud Picker. Pictures: Dan Linehan
Cloud Picker. Pictures: Dan Linehan

Notes of walnut, dark chocolate, and maple syrup were listed on the packaging, which all tasters could identify. The result is a well-balanced blend with just the right kick. Produced in Dublin, available in Filter George’s Quay, South Main St and Wunderkaffee, Farran, Cork. It is also available in whole and ground beans. Good presentation in a box suitable for a gift.

Score: 10

Soma 250g €13.50

Soma. Picture: Dan Linehan
Soma. Picture: Dan Linehan

Available in whole bean or ground. The black coffee tasters (and even those who prefer it with milk) found this smooth, almost sweet, with caramel and chocolate notes. Use with less milk than with regular coffee for a better hit. Orange is noted on the pack but we didn’t detect it. We got nutty on the nose, and a full, robust flavour, which is not too acidic.

Score: 9

Blue Butterfly 250g €12 1kg €32

Blue Butterfly. Picture: Dan Linehan
Blue Butterfly. Picture: Dan Linehan

We discovered this delicious coffee, indiscernible from the regular version, at Cortado café on the Marina Walk, Cork. It is an excellent product, rich, interesting, with good structure. The kilo bag is good value, and the aroma when opening was a good portent of a rounded mouthful—not too acidic but with a good kick. It can be ordered ground. Perfect for after dinner. Based in Waterford, it is available online at BlueButterfly.ie/shop-coffee.

Score: 9.5

Stone Valley 250g €11 1kg €40

Stone Valley. Picture: Dan Linehan
Stone Valley. Picture: Dan Linehan

Plenty of flavour here, you’d hardly miss the kick of caffeine. Fresh and fruity was our impression more than the notes of toffee, caramel, and milk chocolate listed.

Roasted in Clonakilty, where it is available in the coffee shop, as well as Bright Side café, Washington Street, Cork and speciality food shops (such as Bradleys Cork, on order). Also, online stonevalleyroasters.com.

Score: 9.25

Cork Coffee Roasters Swiss decaf 227g €9.50

Cork Coffee Roasters, Swiss Decaf. Picture: Dan Linehan
Cork Coffee Roasters, Swiss Decaf. Picture: Dan Linehan

Plenty of fresh flavours here, with some depth of nutty and chocolate flavours and a gentle kick. You wouldn’t miss the caffeine much. Both black and white drinkers were happy. Nicely rounded. Available in its four Cork shops and Roughty Foodie, English Market, Cork.

Score: 9

Velo Colombia sugarcane decaf 200g €7.90

Velo. Picture: Dan Linehan
Velo. Picture: Dan Linehan

The packet says it has flavours of malted chocolate, Christmas cake and dried apple, and we agreed there were hints of all of those with some depth of flavour not found in those that didn’t make the cut. There is also a Half Caff coffee (200g €7), which has more of a kick but somehow less depth of flavour.

Score: 8.5

Badger & Dodo whole bean 250g €12.43

Badger & Dodo. Picture: Dan Linehan
Badger & Dodo. Picture: Dan Linehan

Our black coffee drinkers particularly enjoyed the mellowness of this one and noted a fruitiness. When we added more coffee for cappuccino drinkers, it was extra satisfying. The softness of chocolate notes and a very slight nuttiness (walnut/pecan) blend nicely. Roasted in Fermoy.

Score: 8

Mahers Pure Coffee 100g €3.75

Mahers. Picture: Dan Linehan
Mahers. Picture: Dan Linehan

These medium-strength decaf whole beans can be ground in the shop and are available in larger quantities. The flavour has some depth with a hint of nuts and a little kick at the end. One taster preferred the Aldi Alcafe Smooth Roast (good value at 227g €2.09), but tasters’ marks won Mahers a Top 8 place when added up. From a wide selection of regular coffee. Available in the Oliver Plunkett St, Cork shop and online at Maherspurecoffee.ie.

Score: 7.75

More in this section