If you would like to submit a contribution to our Readers Blog section then follow this link. Be sure to include your full name, address and contact number otherwise your submission will not be considered for publication. We will contact you prior to publication.

Using made-up statistics hides reality women face on abortion

Recent claims that the Eighth Amendment has resulted in 100,000 babies being born need
to be looked at from another perspective. It implies that the amendment has forced 100,000 women to continue with pregnancies whether they wanted to or not and regardless of their circumstances.

If that seems more like a boast from Ceausescu’s grim Romania in the 1980s than something to celebrate, maybe that is because the Eighth Amendment dates from that era.

In fact, our constitutional ban only prevents those who are too ill or those who cannot afford to travel from accessing abortion services outside Ireland. Those with money have always exercised their right
to choose in England and other countries.

We even wrote their “freedom” to travel for abortions into the Constitution in a referendum in 1992. The word “freedom” was used because if we were to give women a “right” to travel the State might have to pay their costs.

In most European countries
(except the Vatican and Malta) abortion is legal — and offered as a health service — because it is recognised in European democracies that there are many valid reasons why women may terminate pregnancies.

They include when they have
been raped, are experiencing a pregnancy that will not end with a live child, when women cannot cope physically or mentally, or they simply cannot afford another child.

It is time that Ireland also recognised that women can have very complex and different experiences of pregnancy; that our state fails to support and value parenting, provide affordable childcare, or even to ensure that educational opportunities are genuinely free and equal; and that many families struggle on low incomes and live with the threat of — and increasingly experience — homelessness.

Quoting made-up statistics only hides the realities many women, couples and families face when considering whether someone can take on the lifelong and crucially important work of motherhood. It is time to repeal the Eighth Amendment and deal honestly with these issues.

Dr Sandra McAvoy

Douglas Road


Related Articles

Fianna Fáil may recruit Tóibín over 8th stance

TDs in talks to form new pro-life party

‘Constant battle’ over rogue crisis pregnancy agencies

HSE in 'constant battle' to be found ahead of 'rogue' crisis pregnancy agencies in online searches

More in this Section

Readers Blog: Adams will still hold sway after he retires

Readers Blog: Northern Irish human rights face Brexit threat

Readers' Blog: Forget rugby, it’s time to fund other, ‘smaller’ sports

Readers' Blog: What if growth was no longer needed?

Breaking Stories

Senator says legal defences possible for those accused following vigilante style sting operations

Data shows major jump in numbers of patients on hospital trolleys

Judge calls for ’better way’ to deal with such cases as boy with cerebral palsy awarded €15m

Gardaí seize €100k and nine cars in 11 raids in Co. Kerry


Making Cents: Black Friday is an opportunity - but be careful

Dishing out the chores

Quietly successful: Meet the man behind ECM Records

More From The Irish Examiner