Votes for the diaspora: A pointless distraction

NOTHING has changed since the phrase ‘no taxation without representation’ was, apparently, coined by American lawyer James Otis in the 1760s, who wanted to end British colonisation of his nascent country, to undermine its core truth.

Its opposite — no representation without taxation — seems as rational, and a trustworthy guide in how public affairs might be ordered.

That linking of representation to tax might not appeal to the near 50% of people in work in Ireland but who pay no income tax, however, in the context of voting rights to Irish citizens abroad, it seems a valid line in the sand. 

Why should Irish people in Perth or Paris have a vote in our elections?

They will not have to face the consequences. We would and that is surely the essence of participatory democracy. Why should Irish-Americans vote, say, on our EU membership?

The logic behind the proposal seems based on a kind of misplaced sentiment, rather than a hope to strengthen our democracy. It is a kind of franchise-by-Skype silliness that might sustain a near-dead conversation until something better occurs. 

Today’s proposals confine that possibility to presidential elections, but that is a tad dishonest — if the facility is offered in one vote, how can it be denied in another? 

Government faces many challenges, some at crisis level. Have they really nothing better to do than indulge and encourage this kind of pointless, unnecessary distraction?

© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved

Email Updates

Receive our lunchtime briefing straight to your inbox

More in this Section

Sisters of Charity withdraw - A profound, challenging acceptance

Old alliances no longer reliable - Battle lines are being drawn

A tour too far - Players exploited and vulnerable

Most regulators under-resourced - Our pretend policing is a real cancer


Breaking Stories

Headmaster foresees issues as school waiting lists to be phased out

Three young people escape after incident at Oberstown youth detention centre

Leo Varadkar rubbishes reports on health ministry refusal

Latest: New 10-year plan for free GP and hospital care a ‘chance to take politics out of health’ - Harris

Lifestyle

Limmy is prompting outrage with his Glaswegian glee

Skibbereen exhibition to highlight links between West Cork and Cornwall

MAKING CENTS: More for homebuyers to think about than prices and rates

What you need to know when choosing a nursing home

More From The Irish Examiner