Keane, Brady, McGrath top Irish trio, says Giles

RTÉ pundit John Giles, pictured, will be signing copies of his compelling new book The Great & The Good at Eason’s, Patrick’s Street in Cork city today.

In the book, the former Ireland and Leeds legend looks back on over 50 years of football and Giles nominates Roy Keane, fellow RTÉ pundit Liam Brady and Paul McGrath as the top three Irish players he has seen.

Keane, Giles argues, was “the opposite of a sunshine boy. If I was in a battle to win a match, to save my life, and I had to choose one player to be by my side, I think I would want to have Roy Keane there”.

Assessing the Premier League era, Giles isn’t afraid to be controversial.

He speaks glowingly of Paul Scholes, John Terry and Tony Adams but goes against conventional wisdom in saying Ryan Giggs, Thierry Henry, Dennis Bergkamp and Eric Cantona fall below the level of the true greats.

Giles argues Giggs lacks concentration at vital moments, Henry failed to fulfil his true potential, Bergkamp couldn’t be relied upon when the going got tough and Cantona never delivered for Man United in Europe.

© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved

Email Updates

Receive our lunchtime briefing straight to your inbox

More in this Section

Cork City's squad-building ‘nearly done’

Patrick Roberts: Man City’s teenage star scores for Celtic against parent club

Ciaran Kilduff: Dundalk can bounce back

Claudio Ranieri has no fears for future as Leicester stars are rested


Breaking Stories

Leicester faced an embarrassing thrashing - and Tottenham a thrilling win - in the last of the Champions League group stages

Champions League wrap: Borussia Dortmund clinch top spot ahead of Real Madrid

Spurs finally end winless Wembley run

Leicester lose unbeaten record in five-goal humiliation

Lifestyle

After 70 years you can now watch Ireland's first feature film 'The Dawn'

Five 'Very Important Patients' at Temple Street pick the best toys of 2016

Full disclosure in Oliver Stone's new film about CIA whistleblower Edward Snowden

What to buy for the most awkward people in your life this Christmas

More From The Irish Examiner