9-12C
There will be a fair amount of cloud and the chance of a few showers.

Find a...

Date Job Car Home










 




More crowd trouble for Munster Council

ENDEAVOUR yes, but skill?

Plenty of the former, less of the latter, reflected Waterford’s Michael ‘Brick’ Walsh after yesterday’s Munster SHC semi-final which saw the Déise hang on for a two-point win over Clare.

It ended with first the Banner’s Darach Honan juggling, and losing, a ball he should have buried for the match-winner; ditto Waterford’s Thomas Ryan, who also fluffed a match-winning goal chance. The profligacy didn’t end there — Patrick Kelly’s 20m free was turned away by his opposite number Stephen O’Keeffe, when a goal would have pinched it for Clare.

‘Brick’ may have a future as an analyst.

So much for post-mortems. And wayward predictions from professional forecasters. Met Eireann suggestions that we might be flooded out of Semple Stadium were wide of the mark as we basked in June sunshine.

However, the gloom in previous days about the size of the crowd was sadly accurate. The official attendance of 12,296 looked even frailer in the ground itself, with plenty of blue and gold seating visible, and therefore empty, in both stands.

A consensus on ticket prices seemed to be determined early last week – a negative consensus at that — and an attendance of under 13,000 paying customers suggests the Munster Council will need to revisit the issue. Here was a referendum determined largely by absentee ballots.

For the game itself, presumptions about Waterford’s greater experience and Clare’s supposed naivete held up under scrutiny in the first half. Waterford’s two goals were a study in contrasts: Eoin Kelly’s penalty strike was a classically sweet contact, but Shane Walsh’s improvised shovelling of the ball over the line to avoid getting hooked was clearly the work of a man unfazed by white line fever.

Incidentally, the pundits were incorrect in saying Kelly’s penalty should have been a free out. The basic principles of jurisprudence tell us that two wrong don’t make a right, and the foundation stone of good refereeing is that you can only call what you see: if James McGrath didn’t see Kelly’s initial foul he couldn’t give a free out.

While we don’t often comment on the officials here, we didn’t have McGrath pegged as a fan of Ralph Waldo Emerson. The Westmeath referee’s attitude to crime and punishment in the match adhered closely to one of Emerson’s great phrases: a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of a little mind.

Clare had a first-half goal of their own, and it was a tribute to their virtues — John Conlon finished well, but it was created by the workrate of Clare forwards like Padraig Collins hassling Waterford defenders and turning over possession. Conlon’s two late points made it 2-8 to 1-9 at the break.

The Banner were more energetic on the resumption, and the one-in, all-in approach was typified by the fact that their go-ahead point was scored by keeper Patrick Kelly, pointing a free from his own half.

Old dogs live for hard roads, though. Yesterday’s win means several Waterford players are looking at a seventh Munster final appearance, and the experience earned in those campaigns meant players like Stephen Molumphy, Seamus Prendergast and Kevin Moran were able to win possession at vital times.

“I think that was crucial,” said Waterford manager Michael Ryan afterwards. “I was delighted with the blend we had coming into the game. We had four or five lads making their debut, but we had a nice blend of youth and experience. There’s no doubt about it, in the cauldron of a Munster championship game you need experience, and some of those guys came up trumps today.”

By contrast, Clare had three bad wides from frees in the last ten minutes, not counting Kelly’s late effort on goal, which was a difficult prospect given the angle he had to deal with.

Banner boss Davy Fitzgerald wasn’t minded to blame his players: “We had the chances. But I’m not going to give out to the lads. They gave everything they had. I was laughing today at certain stuff, with people making us favourites. So many of those Waterford guys have been in All-Ireland semi-finals and Munster finals. And they didn’t get the credit they deserved.

“They’re great players – the whole lot of them. Fair play to them and I wish them the very best in the Munster final. Trust me, our lads will be back again. There’s a lot of fight in them.”

Clare for the qualifiers, then. Waterford for the big show in July, with a point to prove after last year’s annihilation. And after yesterday’s attendance, the final score won’t be the only figure under scrutiny.

© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved

Home

More from the Irish Examiner