The deal reached on scrapping the reviled promissory notes received a muted welcome last night with questions raised over how effective it would be in ridding the country of Anglo Irish Bank’s poisonous legacy.
Enda Kenny described it as a “historic step on the road to economic recovery” but concerns were raised that it may also have lengthened the road the country must travel to put the Anglo disaster behind it.
And while Finance Minister Michael Noonan indicated it would provide breathing space for the exchequer and growing room for the economy, opponents argued that given the scale of the overall national economic woes, it amounted simply to making us all live within only a slightly bigger cage...
Q. What has the deal achieved?
A. It has replaced the short-term, high-interest promissory note payable at a rate of €3.1bn annually until 2023 with long-term, low-interest bonds payable on interest-only terms until 2038 with principal payments to be spread between then and 2053.
Q. How will that help us?
A. Straight away there is financial relief as we don’t have to make this year’s payment of €3.1bn which was due at the end of March. Longer term, we won’t have to borrow the €20bn that would have been needed to meet the remaining annual payments. We will have to pay interest on the bonds, but initially the Central Bank will hold the bonds so interest will be paid within the State. The Central Bank will gradually sell the bonds on the open market so the interest liability will be more evident down the line.
Q. Is there a downside?
A. We would have been clear of the heaviest demands of the promissory notes by 2023, with smaller payments continuing until 2031, but we won’t even begin to pay back the principal on the new bonds until 2038 and will continue to make principal payments until 2053, which passes the burden on to the next two generations.
Q. Will the deal ultimately cost us more?
A. In simple terms, probably, but after 40 years of inflation, the sums we will pay back in 2053 will be considerably less in real terms than they are in today’s values. The promissory note payments plus interest would have come to a total of €48bn, which would still be a colossal sum in 18 years’ time.
Q. How will the deal affect the next budget?
A. According to Michael Noonan, it will reduce the need for spending cuts and tax increases by about €1bn. To put that in context, Budget 2013 last December imposed €3.5bn in cuts and extra taxes, so the new deal would knock almost a third off that. It will not, however, eliminate the need for further cuts and tax rises in Budget 2014.
Q. What will it do for the economy in general?
A. The markets have responded well, regarding it as a positive move, and anything that boosts investors’ confidence in Ireland is good for business. Mr Noonan said he believed it would aid growth and job creation but it would be hard to pin any such improvements on any one development.
Q. So how big a deal is the deal?
A. Taken in isolation, it was nowhere near as radical as getting a debt write-off, but it is a much more manageable reorganisation of the Anglo-related debts and will perhaps embolden the Government to seek restructuring of other debts.
Unfortunately, the former Anglo and its now equally defunct replacement, IBRC, were only a small part of the country’s problems. We have paid alm-ost €70bn in total bailing out former and existing banks, our total national debt is almost €200bn and day-to-day Government expenditure still exceeds revenue by billions of euro. It’s a case of one small step on a very long road.
Quinns to fight liquidation
The Quinn family are believed to already be preparing a legal challenge to the legislation liquidating the former Anglo Irish Bank.
A key section of Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Bill 2013 provides for an immediate stay on all proceedings against IBRC.
It states that no further action can be issued against the bank without the High Court’s consent.
The Quinns were due to begin an action against the bank in April over the legality of €2.3bn in debts due to the bank.
The new bill does not, however, stop the action IBRC has been taking against the Quinns in its pursuit of €2.8bn which it claims is owed to it.
Last night the Impartial Reporter newspaper in Fermanagh reported that the Quinn family are to challenge the liquidation legislation in court.
It quoted a source as saying: “The legislation was passed hoping the family would drop their case but that won’t be happening. The family is very confident of achieving a positive result and are more determined than ever.”
Earlier in the day, the Quinn Manufacturing Group, in which IBRC had a minority sharing of 24.9%, had issued a statement saying the liquidation had no impact whatever on its business.
It said IBRC had no involvement in the management of the group.
— Stephen Rogers
There were six IBRC executives earning over €500k each year, including CEO Mike Aynsley, whose package was €633,000.
They will now be entitled to statutory redundancy payments. In Mr Aynsley’s case this amounts to €1,200 per year for every year he was with the bank. He joined in 2009, so if he decides to return to his native Australia, he will have a cheque for €4,800.
Mr Aynsley was contracted to run IBRC until 2015. But because it was liquidated, all employment contracts are null and void.
The salary levels of the senior management team at IBRC caused a huge public backlash when they emerged through a parliamentary question last November.
Chief financial officer Jim Bradley had a basic salary of €400,000 but pension contributions and expenses pushed the total package over €500,000. The head of asset recoveries, Tom Hunersen; the head of specialised asset management, Richard Woodhouse; and the head of Irish recoveries, Mark Layther were on similar packages.
— John Walsh
Picture: Elliemai O’Hare, 2, of Boreenmanna Rd, Cork, who will be aged 42 when the last of the payments for Anglo will be made. Picture: Jim Coughlan
© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved
Three men in their 30s and 40s were being questioned last night about a horrific sex attack on two little girls attending a birthday party.
Two men have been arrested following a burglary at a Co Longford shop.
A man in Cork has become the second male motorcyclist to lose his life on the country's roads in less than 24 hours.
A threatened strike that would have seen ESB energy taken off the grid has been avoided after unions said their industrial dispute with management has been resolved.
A man and a woman have been injured following a shooting incident in Tullamore this evening.
The local authority which voted against making Nelson Mandela a freeman of Cork in 1987 was asked, just hours before his death, to "right that wrong".
It'll be a white December, but no snow on Christmas Day, according to long-range weather guru Ken Ring.
Gardaí in Dublin have today renewed their appeal for any assistance in locating missing teenager Leon Quirke.
A 50-year-old man has been killed, after his motorcycle and a car were in collision near Roundwood in Co Wicklow.
Mandate Trade Union has criticised the decision by Marks and Spencer to open some of its smaller stores around the country today - while more than 2,000 workers are on strike.
Taxpayers have forked out €5m for college fees for hundreds of staff across government departments under the Coalition.
From political posters to bottles of wine and kitchen aprons, the face and name of Nelson Mandela are a potent commercial and political brand in South Africa. Little wonder it's so sought after — and the source of occasional squabbles.
While Taoiseach Enda Kenny was downing the saki and talking up Ireland in Japan, the Government was receiving a PR boost from a US publication that is frequently described as America's business bible.
In the run-up to offering a happy gluten-free Christmas, The Foods of Athenry has clocked up four UK Great Taste awards, three new product launches, two Blás na hÉireann medals and a sales launch in the UK.
The Munster Council have commenced a new initiative aimed at growing numbers in urban areas.
Given the trauma of the past week and the likelihood the Heineken Cup will not feature the best clubs the European game has to offer going forward, there is a premium on winning the tournament this season.
STANDING up, as she's about to leave, Louise Phillips, author of the just-named Irish Crime Novel of the Year The Doll's House may have cried as she told me about the dark place where her novels originate.
I'M from a town in Co Clare. If I was around in that town 50 years ago, and got it into my head to make a movie, I can't imagine where I would start.
Long-range weather guru Ken Ring is predicting a frosty Christmas for Ireland this year, with the south of the country most likely to get a festive snowfall.
IT IS, at best, a troubled relationship. We have in this country a prof-essional group made up of individuals we all hope we never get to meet.
It's just the backing she needed in her race against time for a Christmas miracle.
The earliest known settlers in Co Cork were hunter-gatherers who lived near Fermoy more than 10,100 years ago.
Christmas has come early for animal lover Cormac Williams whose pet donkey, named Tulip, has given birth to twin foals.
A snow-coveredforest, magic fairydust — and real life husky puppies. Welcome to Santa's grotto, Franc-style.
Sometime next year, certainly in league and possibly championship, the veteran secretary of the Sarsfields club will smile across at the first-year secretary of Erin's Own, and give a knowing nod.
The grandmother of a toddler with Down's syndrome has been waiting a year for a response from the Taoiseach and three government ministers to correspondence about disability cuts referred to them on her behalf by the troika.
A CONFERENCE at London's Royal Society next week will discuss ways to reduce emissions from gases blamed for causing rising temperatures.
A consortium that owns some of Cork's best-known pubs has initiated proceedings aimed at preventing Irish Bank Resolution Corporation selling its loans to Nama.