HSE refuses to explain why ‘clerical error’ wasn’t reported as data breach

The HSE will not explain why the “clerical error” at the centre of the false Tusla sex abuse claims against whistleblower Maurice McCabe failed to be registered as a data protection breach.

A HSE spokesperson refused to comment yesterday, despite saying last weekend the “administrative error” was referred to its data protection section when uncovered — meaning it should have automatically been identified as a data protection breach.

As revealed by the Irish Examiner and RTÉ’s Prime Time programme last Thursday, Sergeant McCabe was the subject of false sex abuse claims detailed in a Tusla file by a HSE counsellor at the height of the penalty points scandal in 2014.

Information included in the file that he acted inappropriately with a child was subsequently found to be false and after it was “copy-and-pasted” into the file by a HSE counsellor.

However, the case remained active for more than two years.

Under strict HSE protocols, any “administrative error” in a file must be registered as a data protection breach with its regional manager for data protection and consumer affairs in order to ensure a repeat offence does not occur.

Despite the fact the HSE has described the mistake as an “administrative error”, the ‘cut and paste’ fiasco failed to be registered.

Details released to The Journal website under the Freedom of Information Act show that between April 2014 and April 2015, a total of 103 data protection breaches were reported.

These breaches involved medical notes being sent to the wrong patients, a Tusla report being attached to an information booklet and posted by mistake, and a patient’s chart being left on a garden wall.

They also include patient files which were discovered by a member of the public in the drawer of a filing cabinet in a second-hand furniture shop, and a diary containing sensitive client information which was misplaced and found on the roof of her car.

However, despite the details involved, no reference whatsoever was made during the period to the false accusations of sexual abuse against Sgt McCabe.

Asked to comment on why the error was not registered, a spokesperson said the HSE will not comment on any aspect of the McCabe case other than to say it is “currently in the process of gathering all files and putting in place an internal review”.

© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved

Email Updates

Receive our lunchtime briefing straight to your inbox

Related Articles

Charleton: Lies to inquiry will be costly to the public

An inquiry that is both lofty and grounded

Can journalistic privilege be used to avoid giving evidence?

LATEST: Tribunal chairman Peter Charleton asks anyone with relevant information to come forward in next two weeks

More in this Section

20 years of horror: Grace returned to foster home after hospital saw her for bruising on thighs and breasts

Job courses extend beyond unemployed

Can journalistic privilege be used to avoid giving evidence?

Coveney: Leadership is about vision, not private issues


Breaking Stories

'Grace' case: HSE reiterates apology to woman abused at a foster home

Gardaí appeal for witnesses to armed robbery in Dublin

Euromillions prizewinner pledges to help Dublin homeless

Oxfam claims profits shifted through Ireland hurt developing countries

Lifestyle

Eight things we learned at the Audi Dublin International Film Festival

Carol Drinkwater still has a thirst to act

Exploring Ethiopia: Novelties abound in the cradle of mankind on horn of Africa

Sky Matters: Sirius will be visible in the middle of March

More From The Irish Examiner