FF accuses Phil Hogan of misleading the Dáil

Embattled Environment Minister Phil Hogan has been accused of misleading the Dáil over the massive €180m start-up costs for Irish Water.

Phil Hogan: FF misleading with 'selective quote'

The charge was made by Fianna Fáil environment spokesperson Barry Cowen after he claimed Mr Hogan told a Dáil committee in Nov 2012 that the launch bill would be €10m.

Mr Cowen said it has since been revealed that the key Government Economic Management Council had agreed the €180m figure three months before Mr Hogan gave evidence to the Oireachtas environment committee.

“Either Minister Hogan deliberately lied about how much taxpayers’ money was being spent on setting up Irish Water, or he accidentally gave a gross underestimation to the Oireachtas Environment Committee in November 2012,” said Mr Cowen.

“Either way, we now know that when Minister Hogan publicly stated that the cost would be €10m, he knew that €180m had already been committed three months previously.

“I believe that Minister Hogan is deliberately trying to confuse people to save his own political skin as this controversy rumbles on.

Mr Hogan hit back by insisting Fianna Fáil was being misleading with a “selective quote”.

He said the €10m figure referred only to the costs that would be provided by his department, not the overall figure.

Mr Hogan accused opponents of trying to smear Bord Gais workers.

Mr Hogan admitted start-up costs for Irish Water were “substantial”, but said the ESB had spent €100m on a billing system in 2005.

He accused opposition parties of twisting the facts to suit a political agenda.

Mr Hogan came under sustained criticism in the Dáil over his failure to get a grip on the launch costs for the metering monopoly, which is to spend €86m on outside consultants.

He said that Irish Water would produce huge savings for the State.

“The Government simply cannot continue with the current situation with over €1bn of taxpayers’ money being spent annually on water services, but with 40% leaking into the ground,” said Mr Hogan. “Furthermore, there are significant additional requirements for capital investment in water to meet our EU water quality requirements.

“The establishment of the company will deliver major savings of approximately €2bn over the next eight years.”

Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan said Irish people were now expected to pay for water, while access to it is seen as a right in the developing world.


Related Articles

Government rejects idea of referendum on Irish Water

1,000 km of Victorian piping needs to be replaced at cost of €13bn: Irish Water

Essential water shut down next Tuesday night in Cork will impact 35,000 people

Two men charged with obstructing installation of water meters lose High Court case

More in this Section

Bail for man, 60, accused of sexually assaulting four women in Cork

HSE to explain why it paid 600% drug price rise

River Lee’s first new bridge in decade installed

Drink driver caught for 11th time is jailed


Breaking Stories

M20 Cork-Limerick motorway is priority for Government, according to Finance Minister

Dispute over alleged unlawful occupation of pub may delay Apollo House redevelopment, court hears

Gardaí seek help tracing missing Cork teenager

Homeless woman entitled to costs after legal aid system reached its monthly quota, court rules

Lifestyle

Why a good breakfast is a must for your kids

Facing fears while terrifying punters at Cork's Nightmare Realm

Weathering the storm of 1961: We watched 30 large trees uprooted

Remembering the dead: Poignant reason behind Cork’s Zombie Walk

More From The Irish Examiner