12-15C
A mainly dry day with sunny intervals.

Find a...

Date Job Car Home















Banking pantomime must come to an end

Parts of the commentary on the economy are now reaching the proportions of a pantomime.

In this play the baddies are a race known as bankers who are chased around the stage by do-gooders dressed up as suave commentators and certain media observers.

They carry the bats used to bash the bankers and put them in the pigeonholes that suit our moods.

Instead of thinking about bankers as ordinary humans trying to work earnestly and support families let’s just pitch them on the heap marked “unworthy”.

I was thinking about this last week on a visit to my local Ulster Bank branch. It was a torrid sight, with enraged customers getting stuck in to young tellers who were doing their best to explain the consequences of an IT catastrophe.

No matter that those young bankers were probably on salaries that had been cut, pensions reduced, and working in a branch probably earmarked for closure.

Nope, for now they are just more of the pantomime bankers that all of us like to beat up on and this IT debacle was just another good excuse to take them out for a beating.

I don’t like the generalities that sweep across any public debates about various pieces of Irish life: Bankers are all a disgrace; priests are child abusers; politicians are corrupt; businesspeople are snake oil sales merchants.

It’s a nice, neat classification that thinks in black and white, and helps shape a simpler view of the world. But it is profoundly misplaced.

For sure, there are institutional failures in large organisational structures that bestride our economies.

Banks were allowed to mash together bog-standard retail banking with a complex and highly charged investment banking ethos that corrupted large parts of the financial services sector.

The fault for that outcome does not, however, rest with the foot soldiers. It lies instead at the top of the tree.

Political leaders now have a huge role to play in shaping the financial system in a way that supports the recovery in our economy while ensuring a safe financial system that respects the integrity of those who work in it.

That implies;

(1) building systems that guarantee the banks cannot be corrupted by their political masters;

(2) creating retail banks that cannot be contaminated by an investment banking culture, and;

(3) giving those retail banks the oxygen needed in capital to stimulate lending, a lifeblood in any market economy.

In this new world the banks left in Ireland may be boring but safe entities in which people can work with dignity and respect. That might stop the caricature circus that currently exists.

One of the great dangers we are creating as we navigate through this banking restructuring is the risk of producing a new breed of corruption.

Once banks are owned by politicians the temptation to twist bank policies in support of the agendas of individual ministers is very high.

The chance of turning that into another raft of money-driven corruption in years to come is pronounced.

It will require robust regulators, well resourced forensic police officers, an independent and analytical media, and politicians with true integrity to combat this risk.

Can anyone assure you or I that such a collection of assets will be formed while managing the ongoing crisis that wraps around all our lives?

© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved

Home

More from the Irish Examiner