Savita: Contrasting reactions from India




There have been mixed reactions in India to the death of Savita Halappanavar, who died following a miscarriage at University Hospital Galway.

It has been reported that the 31-year-old dentist was repeatedly refused a medical termination.

The India Times' online edition asked "Are Ireland's Catholic Abortion Laws responsible for Savita's death?"

The media outlet went on to call the Irish Government "religious fundamentalists" over their delay in replacing the "draconian law that bans abortion".

The paper posed the question "Isn't Ireland a first world country?" and wondered if the Government was listening to the people of Ireland's wishes.

They then said "Isn't there a word for countries that base their laws on religion irrespective of common sense and the value of human life... what's the word: Fundamentalist? Taliban-esque? Third World?"

The Times of India focused on the political fallout from the tragedy.

Its report today mentioned Tánaiste Eamon Gilmore's meeting with the Indian ambassador to Ireland, Debashish Chakravarti, due later today.

They went on to report that India's external affairs minister Salman Khurshid said: "It is extremely sad and unfortunate. Whatever the inquiry does, human loss cannot be compensated."

The newspaper also carried an Embassy of Ireland statement that said: "The Irish Prime Minister and the Minister for Health spoke on the matter in Irish Parliament yesterday and expressed their deepest condolences to the husband and family of Mrs Halappanavar.

"The Irish government, at the highest level, is committed to establishing the full circumstances and facts surrounding Mrs Halappanavar's tragic death."

The HSE has said it is in the process of appointing an independent expert to oversee the work of its inquiry into Savita's death.

The review team, and its terms of reference, are expected to be announced later.


Email Updates

Receive our lunchtime briefing straight to your inbox

Related Articles

More in this Section

Govt gives Irish Water €270m to make up for scrapping of charges

Judge who dismissed same sex marriage challenges says courts cannot change laws

Calls to build bridges between TDs and British MPs over Brexit

Garda manhunt continues after double murder in Ballymun


Today's Stories

Trump defends monuments to pro-slavery Confederacy

Shane Ross: No funding until OCI reforms

16 Roses book their place in live TV final

Rio report reveals ‘rotten OCI culture’, says Sports Minister

Lifestyle

Can experiencing awe really make us better people?

Summer solutions to survive the school holidays on a budget

An Inconvenient Sequel offers solutions rather than problems

Irish fans remember Elvis Presley 40 years after his death

More From The Irish Examiner