Recruits row rumbles on between Shatter and GRA

Minister for Justice Alan Shatter (right) attends the Garda Representative Association (GRA) conference in Athlone yesterday. Picture: PA

Justice Minister Alan Shatter has warned rank-and-file garda leaders against damaging relations with the Army in a row over recruits.

In a deepening fall-out, Mr Shatter called on the Garda Representative Association (GRA) to reflect on “unfortunate” remarks made during its annual conference.

“I’m very conscious there’s a very good and close relationship between An Garda Síochána and the Defence Forces,” he said.

“I wouldn’t like to see that relationship damaged.”

Damien McCarthy, outgoing president of the GRA, which represents more than 11,000 grassroots officers, mocked the minister for recruiting soldiers during a Garda staffing freeze.

“Minister, it is remarkable that you continued to recruit members for the Permanent Defence Forces,” he said.

“Is Ireland under attack? Is there a war we are about to join?

“Because we are under attack in the war on crime at home, right here in Ireland.”

The remarks were made during a stinging personal attack on Mr Shatter’s record in office, in which Mr McCarthy branded him soft on crime and claimed gardai felt betrayed by his shortcomings.

Tensions flared again today when Mr Shatter, speaking at the separate Association of Garda Superintendents annual conference, warned against such remarks on the Defence Forces being repeated.

“I would hope that the remarks that were made wouldn’t be repeated in the future and in a calmer moment there will be some reflection on those remarks,” he added.

Mr Shatter said the Garda and Defence Forces had to work together in the interests of the State.

But Mr McCarthy insisted he was not denigrating the Army.

“I made specific reference in the context of the war on crime here at home because in the public service there’s a moratorium,” he said.

“But for this morning to make an insinuation that I denigrated members of the Defence Forces in my address, I don’t accept that.

Mr McCarthy said he never remarked there was no need for recruitment in the Defence Forces.

“I raised the question ’are we at war’ and I said yes, we are, the war on crime,” he said.

Up to 600 vacancies in the Defence Forces are to be filled this year.

A Garda recruitment ban has seen numbers in the force drop 800, according to Mr Shatter.

Gerard P Smith, president of the Association of Garda Superintendents, urged the minister to prioritise 30 empty superintendent posts.

Mr Shatter said it was important that some key vacancies in the force were filled and that he was in talks with public spending minister Brendan Howlin.

“I would be optimistic that we would fill a number of these in the not too distant future,” he said.

Related Articles

Fianna Fáil calls for senior Garda resignation after breath test scandal

More in this Section

Man who developed fibromyalgia after car was struck head on awarded €2m in High Court

Mulhuddart man sentenced to eight years in prison apologises to family of stab victim

Neighbour fined for car-park assault during row over apartment noise

Family heartbroken as brave Alanna Russell passes away

Today's Stories

Quarter of early years staff short on references

Man accused of stealing paninis opts for jury trial

€10m works to rectify dangerous bends on Kerry road

RSA honours man left paralysed after traffic collision 11 years ago for road safety work


Timing is everything as The Frank and Walters revisit 'Grand Parade'

A question of taste: Eileen O'Shea

Eoghan O'Sullivan's picks his highlights of 2017

Learning Points: The ghost of Christmas past is always nostalgia

More From The Irish Examiner