Muslim sanctuary fears are like saying Catholics would flee to Italy: Solicitor

Gardaí have raised concerns that a Dublin man accused of murdering his first cousin may seek sanctuary in a Muslim country.

Stephen Tynan of Knockmore Park in Tallaght is charged with the murder of Andrew Guerrine, who was stabbed to death over two years ago.

Stephen Tynan was arrested twice following the discovery of Andrew Guerinne’s body in south west Dublin in May 2015, but only charged with his murder last month.

In response to Garda concerns he’d flee if granted bail, his barrister Séamus Clarke pointed out that Mr. Tynan has only left Ireland once since his cousin’s death and, more importantly, came back.

Ms. Justice Carmel Stewart heard he has converted to Muslim and Gardaí raised concerns he might seek sanctuary in a Muslim country if he was granted bail.

Mr. Clarke described that objection as "peculiar, highly discriminating and absurd" and compared it to a Catholic fleeing to Italy.

Ms. Justice Stewart accepted the 40-year-old is facing the most serious criminal charge but said he was entitled to the presumption of innocence and granted bail subject to certain strict conditions.

Related Articles

Court hears DNA test in paternity row proves man was not father of one-year-old baby

'Baffled' wife alleges in court yoga group has 'considerable influence' over husband's business affairs

High Court President: Solicitor 'not fit to be member of the profession' and cannot expect 'mercy'

Doctor in High Court challenge against HSE requirement to retire at 65

More in this Section

Europe agrees no physical border between Republic of Ireland and the North, says Theresa May

Fresh appeal launched for information on 2007 murder of Paul Quinn

Taoiseach welcomes Theresa May's 'strengthened language' against physical border with North

Luas operator to conduct emergency exercise this morning

Today's Stories

Bail for man, 60, accused of sexually assaulting four women in Cork

HSE to explain why it paid 600% drug price rise

River Lee’s first new bridge in decade installed

Drink driver caught for 11th time is jailed


Why a good breakfast is a must for your kids

Facing fears while terrifying punters at Cork's Nightmare Realm

Weathering the storm of 1961: We watched 30 large trees uprooted

Remembering the dead: Poignant reason behind Cork’s Zombie Walk

More From The Irish Examiner