Barrister says 'citizens should be terrified' after trial collapses over accuracy of Garda pulse system

By David Raleigh

A criminal trial has collapsed after the State said it could "not vouch for the accuracy" of information recorded on the Garda pulse system relevant to parties involved in the case.

A "lengthy" investigation is to be conducted into the matter, gardaí told the court.

The prosecution said: "It can't be said (it) is accurate".

Commenting on the seriousness of the matter, the accused's barrister said that criminals or suspected criminals were not the only people whose details appeared on pulse.

Indicating that ordinary law abiding citizens could be open to similar "errors", the accused's barrister added: "The ordinary citizens of this country should be terrified in their beds at this development."

The matter arose after one of the parties involved in the case disputed the accuracy of personal information recorded on pulse.

The prosecution said it had emerged that a pulse ID relating to one of the parties appeared to have been "merged" with another person.

Gardaí agreed it appeared an "error" on pulse had been made.

A garda witness gave evidence that this information appeared to be for "a different person entirely".

Asked by the prosecution if gardaí could "vouch for its accuracy", the witness responded: "No".

The garda agreed during cross examination by the accused's barrister that the personal details of "civic minded" members of the public would appear on pulse.

This included valid gun licence holders or eye witnesses reporting road traffic collisions.

The garda also agreed with the accused's barrister that "there now appears to be a problem with the accuracy of the pulse system".

The garda also agreed "ordinary citizens walking the streets don't know if there's an accurate record on them on pulse".

The garda acknowledged: "There can be problems with pulse."

The garda also agreed with the accused's barrister that, "as a matter of law, if (the pulse information) is not accurate, it is not worth the paper it is written on"

Commenting on the impending investigation into the accuracy of the pulse information, the prosecution said "lengthy enquiries will have to made".

The probe will likely take a number of weeks or months to "untangle the (pulse) records", the garda said.

This will include contacting court personnel, as well as sourcing court orders, charge sheets, and contacting members of the force.

More in this Section

Increased jail terms sought for two men jailed after 'fatal burglary'

Varadkar: ’Time has come to allow Irish people have their say’ on abortion

Labour TD Alan Kelly asks whether his phone has been bugged by gardaí

Attempted murder charge dropped after alleged victim dies of natural causes

Today's Stories

Quarter of early years staff short on references

Man accused of stealing paninis opts for jury trial

€10m works to rectify dangerous bends on Kerry road

RSA honours man left paralysed after traffic collision 11 years ago for road safety work


Wishlist: Must-have Christmas gifts and the joy of Ikea

Timing is everything as The Frank and Walters revisit 'Grand Parade'

A question of taste: Eileen O'Shea

Eoghan O'Sullivan's picks his highlights of 2017

More From The Irish Examiner